w/c 15.ix.24

Ordo w/c 15.ix.24

15 SUN	16 MON	17 TUE	18 WED	19 THU	20 FRI	21 SAT
Septem Dolorum Beatæ Mariæ Virginis	Ss. Cornelii Papæ et Cypriani Episcopi, Martyrum	Impressionis Stigmatum S. Francisci	S. Josephi de Cupertino Confessoris	S. Januarii Episcopi et Sociorum Martyrum	Ss. Eustachii et Sociorum Martyrum	S. Matthæi Apostoli et Evangelistæ
Duplex ii	Semi-duplex	Duplex	Duplex	Duplex	Duplex	Duplex ii
Dominica XVII Post Pentecosten	Ss. Euphemiæ, Luciæ et Geminiani Martyrum		Feria Quarta Quattuor Temporum Septembris		Feria Sexta Quattuor Temporum Septembris	Sabbato Quattuor Temporum Septembris

Dolor et amor

Carissimi

I greet you in the name of Our Lord Jesus Christ, whose love surpasses all understanding and whose suffering has opened the gates of eternal life. As we reflect on the mysteries of our faith, particularly during this season where we contemplate the sorrows of the Blessed Virgin Mary, I feel called to share with you a meditation on the profound theme of Dolor et Amor—Sorrow and Love.

In our journey through life, we all encounter moments of sorrow. Whether it is the pain of loss, the burden of illness, the weight of sin, or the difficulties of relationships, sorrow is a universal human experience. Yet, as Christians, we are not called to endure sorrow as the world does—hopelessly and in despair. We are called to unite our sorrows with the love of Christ, transforming them into moments of grace and growth. This is the essence of Dolor et Amor—the inseparable union of sorrow and love in the life of faith.

Sorrow in the Christian Life: An Inevitable Cross

We cannot escape the reality of sorrow. Jesus Himself told us, “In the world, you will have tribulation” (John 16:33). But He did not stop there. He added, “But be of good cheer, I have overcome the world.” Our faith teaches us that sorrow is not an end in itself but a path to deeper communion with Christ, who suffered for us and with us.

The sufferings we endure are part of the cross we are called to carry as followers of Christ. It is in these moments that we can imitate Our Lord most closely. He did not shy away from suffering but embraced it out of love for us. In the Garden of Gethsemane, when faced with the reality of His Passion, Jesus prayed, “Father, if it is possible, let this cup pass from me; nevertheless, not as I will, but as You will” (Matthew 26:39). His acceptance of the Father’s will, even in the face of immense sorrow, teaches us the profound connection between sorrow and love.

The Blessed Virgin Mary: A Model of Dolor et Amor

No one exemplifies Dolor et Amor more perfectly than the Blessed Virgin Mary. As we recently celebrated the Feast of Our Lady of Sorrows, we were reminded of the seven sorrows that pierced her heart throughout her life. From the prophecy of Simeon to the burial of her beloved Son, Mary’s life was marked by deep sorrow. Yet, her sorrows were always accompanied by love—an immeasurable love for God and for her Son, Jesus Christ.

St. Alphonsus Liguori once wrote, “To understand the greatness of Mary’s sorrows, we must understand the greatness of her love for her Son.” Mary’s sorrow was not simply the result of witnessing the suffering of Jesus, but it was the fruit of her immense love for Him. The more we love, the more we suffer when the beloved suffers. Mary’s perfect love for Jesus meant that her heart was intimately united to His, and thus, she shared in His Passion in a way that no one else could.

Through her example, we learn that sorrow, when united with love, becomes redemptive. Mary did not run from her sorrows, nor did she allow them to embitter her. She embraced her suffering with love, offering it to God for the salvation of the world. Her sorrows, which culminated at the foot of the Cross, became a source of grace for all of us. In her, we find a model of how to unite our own sufferings with the love of Christ.

Love Transforms Sorrow

At the heart of our faith is the understanding that love transforms sorrow. Without love, sorrow is simply a burden, a weight that we carry without meaning. But when we embrace sorrow in love—love for God and love for others—it becomes a path to holiness.

St. John of the Cross beautifully expressed this truth when he wrote, “Where there is no love, put love—and you will find love.” This is the Christian response to sorrow. In moments of suffering, we are called to place love where there is pain. This does not mean that we deny the reality of suffering or pretend that it does not exist. Rather, we transform it by bringing love into the midst of it.

In our own lives, we are often tempted to view suffering as something to be avoided at all costs. The world teaches us to seek comfort and pleasure, and it tells us that suffering has no value. But our faith teaches us something radically different. Suffering, when accepted with love, becomes a means of purification and sanctification. It draws us closer to Christ, who suffered for our sake, and it allows us to participate in His redemptive work.

As we face the various sorrows that life presents—whether they be physical pain, emotional distress, or spiritual trials—we must remember that love is what gives them meaning. When we love God with our whole heart, soul, and mind, and when we love our neighbor as ourselves, even the most difficult sorrows are transformed into opportunities for grace.

Sorrow and Love in the Family

One of the most important places where we experience both sorrow and love is within the family. Family life, while a source of great joy and love, is also often a place where we encounter suffering. Whether it is the loss of a loved one, the challenges of raising children, the strain of difficult relationships, or the pain of illness, the family is not immune to sorrow.

Yet, it is in the family that we have the greatest opportunity to practice Dolor et Amor. Just as the Holy Family of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph experienced moments of sorrow—such as the flight into Egypt or the loss of the child Jesus in the Temple—our families, too, are called to embrace both sorrow and love. When we face difficulties in our family life, we must remember that these are moments where we are called to love more deeply, to be patient, to forgive, and to support one another.

In the family, we are also reminded of the power of prayer in times of sorrow. The family that prays together stays together. When sorrow comes into our lives, let us turn to prayer, asking for the intercession of Our Lady of Sorrows, who understands our pain and who will lead us to her Son.

The Eucharist: A Place of Dolor et Amor

The Eucharist, the source and summit of our Christian life, is the perfect expression of Dolor et Amor. In the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, we enter into the mystery of Christ’s Passion, Death, and Resurrection. We encounter the ultimate act of love—the self-giving of Jesus on the Cross—and we are invited to unite our own sorrows with His.

Each time we receive the Eucharist, we are reminded that Christ’s love for us was so great that He was willing to suffer and die for our salvation. In the Eucharist, we also find the strength to carry our own crosses and to transform our sorrows into acts of love. The more we participate in the Eucharist, the more we are conformed to Christ, and the more we are able to embrace Dolor et Amor in our own lives.

A Call to Holiness Through Sorrow and Love

My dear brothers and sisters, as we contemplate the theme of Dolor et Amor, we are reminded that sorrow is not something to be feared or avoided. Rather, it is an invitation to grow in love. When we unite our sorrows with the love of Christ, they become a powerful means of sanctification. Sorrow, transformed by love, leads us to holiness.

St. Thérèse of Lisieux, the Little Flower, whose life was marked by both great love and great suffering, once said, “I understood that all we accomplish, however brilliant, is worth nothing without love.” Her words remind us that love is the only thing that gives meaning to our sorrows, and it is through love that we are drawn closer to God.

As we continue our journey through life, let us not shy away from the sorrows we encounter. Let us embrace them with the love that comes from knowing Christ and uniting our sufferings with His. In this way, we will not only find peace in the midst of sorrow, but we will also discover the joy that comes from loving as Christ loves.

May Our Lady of Sorrows, who knows the depths of Dolor et Amor, intercede for us and help us to bear our sorrows with love and grace, so that we may one day share in the joy of the Resurrection.

In the love of Christ, I remain,

---

The Union of Sorrow and Love

The Feast of the Seven Sorrows of the Blessed Virgin Mary, celebrated on September 15th in the Traditional Latin Rite, is a profound opportunity for the faithful to meditate on the depth of Mary’s sufferings and her intimate participation in the redemptive Passion of her Son. This feast, established to honor the maternal sorrows of the Blessed Virgin, invites us to walk alongside Our Lady through the pivotal moments of her life in which her heart was pierced by sorrow. As we contemplate her sorrows, we come to a deeper understanding of Mary’s role as co-redeemer, a term used to signify her unique participation in the work of salvation, and we are reminded of her steadfast faith, hope, and love.

At the same time, the Seventeenth Sunday After Pentecost presents us with the Gospel reading from Matthew 22:34-40, where Jesus is asked about the greatest commandment. His response is that the greatest commandment is to love God with all one’s heart, soul, and mind, and the second is like it: to love one’s neighbor as oneself. This Gospel passage ties together perfectly with the feast of the Seven Sorrows because it highlights the centrality of love in the Christian life. Mary’s sorrows were a reflection of her perfect love for God and her perfect obedience to His will. Through her sorrows, she teaches us that suffering, when embraced with love, becomes redemptive.

To fully appreciate the spiritual richness of this feast, we will draw on the insights of key spiritual figures, including Dom Prosper Guéranger, Fr. Pius Parsch, Fr. Leonard Goffine, and Fr. Gabriel of St. Mary Magdalene, who have contributed significantly to the Church’s understanding of the role of Mary’s sufferings in the economy of salvation.

The Seven Sorrows of the Blessed Virgin Mary: An Overview

The Seven Sorrows, also known as the Dolors of Mary, are a traditional devotion in the Church that reflect on key moments in the life of the Blessed Virgin where she experienced deep sorrow and pain. These sorrows are not merely instances of personal grief, but moments where Mary, in her maternal heart, fully entered into the redemptive suffering of her Son. The seven sorrows are:

1. The Prophecy of Simeon (Luke 2:25-35)
2. The Flight into Egypt (Matthew 2:13-15)
3. The Loss of the Child Jesus in the Temple (Luke 2:41-50)
4. Mary Meets Jesus on the Way to Calvary (Luke 23:27-31)
5. The Crucifixion and Death of Jesus (John 19:25-30)
6. The Body of Jesus is Taken Down from the Cross (Luke 23:50-54)
7. The Burial of Jesus (Luke 23:55-56)

These sorrows reveal the depth of Mary’s participation in the mystery of redemption. As Dom Prosper Guéranger writes in The Liturgical Year, “The grief of Mary surpasses all other grief. It is the fruit of her love, and she is therefore the one to whom we must have recourse when we wish to learn how to love.”

Each of these sorrows provides a unique perspective on the nature of human suffering and the redemptive power of love. In meditating on these sorrows, we are invited to unite our own sufferings with those of Mary and Jesus, recognizing that suffering, when offered in union with Christ, becomes a powerful means of grace.

The First Sorrow: The Prophecy of Simeon

The first sorrow of Mary occurs when she and St. Joseph present the infant Jesus in the Temple, in accordance with Jewish law. There, they encounter the aged Simeon, who, inspired by the Holy Spirit, recognizes the Messiah in the child Jesus. Simeon blesses the Holy Family but then turns to Mary and delivers a chilling prophecy: “Behold, this child is set for the fall and rising of many in Israel, and for a sign that shall be contradicted. And a sword shall pierce your own soul also” (Luke 2:34-35).

This moment marks the beginning of Mary’s sorrows. Although she was filled with joy at the birth of her Son, this prophecy reveals that Jesus’ mission will involve great suffering—not only for Him but also for her. The sword of sorrow that Simeon speaks of symbolizes the immense spiritual suffering that Mary will endure as she witnesses the opposition to her Son and ultimately His Passion and Death.

Fr. Leonard Goffine, in The Church’s Year, reflects on this moment, noting that “Mary was fully aware that the path of her Son would be one of suffering and rejection. Yet, she did not shrink back from her role as His mother. She accepted this sorrow with faith and trust in God’s plan, knowing that it was through suffering that salvation would come.”

For us, the prophecy of Simeon is a reminder that the Christian life is often marked by suffering. Like Mary, we are called to accept the crosses that come our way with faith, trusting that God’s plan is unfolding even in the midst of our sorrows. Mary’s example teaches us that suffering, when accepted in love and trust, becomes a means of participating in the redemptive work of Christ.

The Second Sorrow: The Flight into Egypt

The second sorrow of Mary takes place shortly after the visit of the Magi, when an angel appears to Joseph in a dream and warns him that King Herod seeks to kill the child Jesus. Joseph immediately takes Mary and Jesus and flees to Egypt, where they remain until Herod’s death. This sudden and perilous flight into a foreign land was a source of great sorrow for Mary, who not only faced the physical hardships of travel but also the deep anxiety of knowing that her Son’s life was in danger.

Fr. Gabriel of St. Mary Magdalene, in Divine Intimacy, reflects on this sorrow, noting that “the flight into Egypt symbolizes the life of every Christian, who must often leave behind the familiar and comfortable in order to follow God’s will. Mary, in her humility, accepted this hardship without complaint, trusting that God would protect her and her Son.”

Mary’s flight into Egypt also reminds us of the plight of refugees and all those who are forced to flee their homes due to violence and persecution. In her suffering, Mary stands in solidarity with all those who experience displacement and insecurity. As we meditate on this sorrow, we are called to pray for those who are displaced and to work for justice and peace in our world.

The Third Sorrow: The Loss of the Child Jesus in the Temple

The third sorrow of Mary occurs when she and Joseph lose the twelve-year-old Jesus during a pilgrimage to Jerusalem. After searching for three days, they find Him in the Temple, sitting among the teachers, listening to them, and asking them questions. When Mary expresses her sorrow at having lost Him, Jesus responds, “Did you not know that I must be about my Father’s business?” (Luke 2:49).

This sorrow was particularly painful for Mary because it involved not only the physical separation from her Son but also the mysterious nature of His mission. Although Mary knew that Jesus was the Son of God, she did not fully understand the implications of His mission at this point. Her sorrow was compounded by the sense of uncertainty and confusion about the path that lay ahead.

Fr. Pius Parsch, in The Church’s Year of Grace, notes that “the loss of Jesus in the Temple is a foreshadowing of the greater loss that Mary will experience at the Crucifixion. Yet, even in her sorrow, Mary trusted that God’s plan was unfolding according to His will, and she submitted herself to that plan with humility.”

For us, this sorrow reminds us that there are times in our spiritual lives when we may feel as though we have “lost” Jesus—times when we feel distant from God or unsure of His presence in our lives. Like Mary, we are called to search for Jesus with perseverance and faith, trusting that He will reveal Himself to us in His own time. This sorrow also teaches us the importance of seeking God’s will in all things, even when we do not fully understand His plan.

The Fourth Sorrow: Mary Meets Jesus on the Way to Calvary

The fourth sorrow of Mary takes place during the Passion of Christ, as she meets her Son on the road to Calvary. This moment, although brief, is one of the most heart-wrenching encounters in the Gospels. Mary, who has loved Jesus with a perfect maternal love, now sees Him suffering under the weight of the cross, His body bruised and bloodied from the scourging, His face marred by the crown of thorns. Their eyes meet, and in that gaze, a deep, unspoken exchange takes place—a mutual offering of suffering and love.

Dom Prosper Guéranger beautifully describes this encounter in The Liturgical Year: “The heart of Mary, already filled with sorrow, was now pierced anew as she saw the state of her beloved Son. Yet, she did not turn away; instead, she joined her sorrow with His, offering it for the salvation of souls. Her love for Jesus and her love for humanity compelled her to continue on the path of suffering with Him.”

This sorrow teaches us the importance of accompanying others in their suffering. Mary’s presence on the road to Calvary is a model for us of how to be with those who are suffering—not by offering platitudes or explanations, but simply by being present and offering our love. In the face of suffering, our presence and compassion can be a source of great comfort and strength.

The Fifth Sorrow: The Crucifixion and Death of Jesus

The fifth sorrow of Mary occurs as she stands at the foot of the cross, watching her Son suffer and die. This is the climax of her sorrows, the moment when the sword of sorrow, prophesied by Simeon, pierces her soul most deeply. As she stands there, she sees her Son—whom she brought into the world, whom she nurtured and loved—now hanging on the cross, abandoned by most of His followers, mocked by His enemies, and enduring the most excruciating physical and spiritual agony.

Fr. Gabriel of St. Mary Magdalene, in Divine Intimacy, writes, “Mary’s heart was crucified with Jesus. She did not merely witness His suffering from a distance; she entered into it, offering her own suffering in union with His for the salvation of the world. Her sorrow was not a passive resignation but an active participation in the mystery of redemption.”

At this moment, Jesus entrusts His mother to St. John and, by extension, to all of us. “Behold your mother” (John 19:27). In this act, Jesus gives Mary to the Church as our spiritual mother, a mother who understands our sorrows and who stands by us in our moments of suffering. Her sorrows are not merely her own; they are shared with all her children.

As we contemplate this sorrow, we are invited to stand with Mary at the foot of the cross, to gaze upon the crucified Christ and to offer our own sufferings in union with His. Mary teaches us how to suffer well—how to offer our pain and sorrow as a gift of love for the salvation of souls. In her, we find a model of perfect trust and surrender to the will of God.

The Sixth Sorrow: The Body of Jesus is Taken Down from the Cross

The sixth sorrow of Mary takes place after Jesus has died. His body is taken down from the cross and placed in His mother’s arms. This moment, often depicted in the Pietà, is one of the most poignant images in Christian art. Mary holds the lifeless body of her Son, the same body that she once cradled in the joy of His birth, now cold and still in death. Her heart is broken, yet her faith remains unshaken.

Fr. Leonard Goffine reflects on this sorrow, noting that “Mary’s grief at holding the body of her dead Son was beyond words, yet she did not despair. She knew that this was not the end, but the prelude to the resurrection. Her faith in God’s promise sustained her, even in the darkest moment of her life.”

For us, this sorrow reminds us that death is not the end. In moments of great loss and grief, we are called to look beyond the pain of the present moment and to trust in the promise of the resurrection. Mary’s sorrow teaches us to hold fast to hope, even when everything around us seems hopeless.

The Seventh Sorrow: The Burial of Jesus

The final sorrow of Mary occurs as she watches the body of Jesus being laid in the tomb. This moment marks the end of her earthly relationship with her Son, yet it also marks the beginning of her role as the Mother of the Church. In this sorrow, Mary lets go of Jesus, trusting that God’s plan will be fulfilled through the resurrection.

Fr. Pius Parsch, in The Church’s Year of Grace, writes, “Mary’s sorrow at the burial of her Son was tempered by her unwavering faith in the resurrection. She knew that, just as the grain of wheat must fall to the ground and die in order to bear fruit, so too must her Son pass through death in order to bring forth new life.”

As we meditate on this sorrow, we are reminded of the importance of trust in the face of loss. Like Mary, we are called to let go of the things we cling to, trusting that God will bring forth new life from the seeds of our sorrows.

The Seventeenth Sunday After Pentecost: The Commandment of Love

In the commemoration of the Seventeenth Sunday After Pentecost, the Gospel reading from Matthew 22:34-40 presents us with the two greatest commandments: to love God with all our heart, soul, and mind, and to love our neighbor as ourselves. These commandments, given by Christ, are the foundation of the Christian life. They are also the foundation of Mary’s life, as she perfectly exemplified both love for God and love for neighbor.

Mary’s love for God was total and complete. From the moment of her Immaculate Conception, she was filled with the love of God, and throughout her life, she lived in perfect obedience to His will. Her sorrows were a reflection of her love, for love is the measure of suffering. The more we love, the more we suffer when the beloved suffers. Mary’s perfect love for Jesus meant that her heart was pierced by His sufferings, yet she never wavered in her love for God or her trust in His plan.

Mary’s love for her neighbor is also evident in her sorrows. She suffered not only for her own sake but for the sake of all humanity. Her participation in the Passion of Christ was a gift of love for us, her spiritual children. As St. Alphonsus Liguori writes, “Mary suffered willingly for us, offering her Son for our salvation. She is truly our Mother, for she bore us in sorrow at the foot of the cross.”

The commandment to love God and neighbor is not an abstract ideal; it is lived out in the concrete reality of suffering, sacrifice, and self-giving. Mary’s example shows us how to live this commandment in our own lives, particularly in the midst of suffering. By uniting our sufferings with those of Christ, we participate in the redemptive love that flows from the cross.

Conclusion: Sorrow Transformed by Love

The Feast of the Seven Sorrows of the Blessed Virgin Mary, together with the commemoration of the Seventeenth Sunday After Pentecost, invites us to reflect deeply on the themes of sorrow, love, and redemption. Mary’s sorrows were not merely personal griefs; they were acts of love, offered in union with the suffering of her Son for the salvation of the world.

As we meditate on the sorrows of Mary, we are called to unite our own sufferings with hers and with those of Christ, trusting that through suffering, God brings about new life. Mary’s example teaches us that love is the measure of suffering, and that through love, suffering can be transformed into a powerful means of grace.

In her sorrow, Mary stands with us in our own trials, offering us her maternal comfort and intercession. She teaches us to trust in God’s plan, even when it involves the cross, and to love with a heart that is willing to suffer for the sake of others.

As we contemplate the sorrows of Mary, let us ask for her intercession, that we may bear our own crosses with the same patience and love, and that we may grow in our love for God and for our neighbor, following her example of perfect obedience and trust.

Mater Dolorosa, ora pro nobis.

---

Sorrow and Love: Remaining Steadfast Amidst the Modernist Crisis in the Church

In the contemporary landscape of the Church, Traditional Catholics find themselves in a situation filled with deep sorrow, as they witness what is often described as the modernist crisis. This crisis manifests in doctrinal confusion, liturgical changes, and the erosion of the once clear and unshakable teachings of the Church. Yet in these turbulent times, we are called not to despair but to respond with love—a love deeply rooted in the faith, in the truth, and in the Church’s sacred traditions. As Christ’s Passion was marked by both sorrow and love, so too is our journey as Catholics today.

The purpose of this reflection is to encourage the faithful to persevere amidst this crisis, understanding that sorrow and love (Dolor et Amor) are inseparable. In times of great trial and suffering, it is love that transforms our sorrow into a redemptive offering, and it is love that strengthens our resolve to remain steadfast in the truth of Christ. The modernist crisis is a cross that we must bear, but through love, this cross becomes the means of our sanctification and the purification of the Church.

I. The Modernist Crisis: A Brief Overview
To understand how sorrow and love are intertwined in the modernist crisis, we must first grasp the nature of this crisis and its effects on the Church. The modernist crisis can be traced back to the intellectual and cultural movements of the 19th and 20th centuries, which sought to reinterpret Catholic teachings in light of contemporary philosophies. These movements challenged the Church’s doctrines, especially concerning revelation, the nature of Christ, and the authority of the Church.

Pope St. Pius X, in his encyclical Pascendi Dominici Gregis (1907), identified modernism as the “synthesis of all heresies.” He warned that modernism was not just an external threat to the Church, but an internal one, infiltrating the minds and hearts of clergy and theologians. According to St. Pius X, modernism sought to reduce divine revelation to mere human experience and to subject the truths of faith to the changing whims of culture and science. This denial of the objectivity and immutability of truth lies at the heart of the modernist crisis.

The effects of modernism have only grown more pronounced over the past century, particularly in the aftermath of the Second Vatican Council (1962-1965). While the council itself did not teach heresy, many of its interpretations have led to widespread confusion and ambiguity. The liturgical changes that followed Vatican II—especially the introduction of the Novus Ordo Mass—have been particularly painful for Traditional Catholics, who see in these changes a loss of the reverence, beauty, and doctrinal clarity that marked the Traditional Latin Mass (TLM). Additionally, modernist ideas have influenced moral theology, leading to a weakening of the Church’s teachings on issues such as contraception, marriage, and the sanctity of life.

For Traditional Catholics, this crisis is not merely a matter of preference or nostalgia for the past. It is a deeply spiritual battle over the very identity of the Church and her mission to safeguard the truth. The sorrow felt by many is the sorrow of witnessing the Bride of Christ in a state of disarray, struggling to uphold the eternal truths of the faith in a world that is increasingly hostile to them.

II. Sorrow in the Face of the Crisis
The sorrow experienced by Traditional Catholics is deeply personal and spiritual. It is the sorrow of witnessing the Church, which has been entrusted with the deposit of faith, seemingly compromise with the world. This sorrow is not born out of bitterness or resentment but out of love for the Church and a desire to see her remain faithful to her mission. It is the sorrow of seeing the liturgy, which is meant to be the highest expression of the Church’s worship, reduced in some places to a casual or even irreverent spectacle. It is the sorrow of seeing doctrines that once stood as clear, unambiguous teachings now open to interpretation or redefinition.

This sorrow mirrors, in many ways, the sorrow of the Blessed Virgin Mary as she stood at the foot of the Cross. Mary’s heart was pierced with sorrow as she witnessed her Son suffer and die, yet her sorrow was born out of love—love for Jesus and love for the salvation of souls. Similarly, our sorrow in witnessing the Church’s current struggles is a sorrow born out of love—love for Christ, love for His Church, and love for the truth.

Dom Prosper Guéranger, in his classic work The Liturgical Year, writes about the sorrow of the Church in times of trial. He notes that the Church, like her divine Spouse, must endure periods of suffering and purification, just as Christ endured His Passion. “The Church,” Guéranger writes, “is at once the mystical body of Christ and the Bride of Christ. As such, she must pass through her own Passion in order to enter into glory.” This Passion of the Church is what many Traditional Catholics are experiencing today—a time of suffering, confusion, and sorrow, but one that ultimately leads to renewal and resurrection.

St. Paul reminds us that “sorrow for God’s sake produces a repentance that leads to salvation” (2 Corinthians 7:10). The sorrow we feel in response to the modernist crisis must not lead us to despair but to a deeper repentance and a more profound love for the Church. It is a sorrow that can purify our hearts, stripping away complacency and lukewarmness, and renewing our commitment to the faith.

III. The Love That Transforms Sorrow
While sorrow is a natural and appropriate response to the crisis, it cannot remain alone. Sorrow without love leads to despair, anger, and division. But when sorrow is united with love, it becomes a powerful force for renewal and transformation. Love is what transforms our sorrow into a redemptive offering, allowing us to participate in the mystery of the Cross and to unite our sufferings with those of Christ.

St. John of the Cross, the great mystic and Doctor of the Church, speaks of the transformative power of love in the midst of suffering. He writes, “Where there is no love, put love, and you will find love.” In the face of sorrow and suffering, our task as Catholics is to put love into those situations—love for Christ, love for the Church, and love for souls. It is through this love that our sorrow is transformed, and we find peace and strength to persevere.

This love is not merely an emotion or sentiment; it is an active, willing participation in the good of the Church and the salvation of souls. It is the kind of love that St. Pius X exhibited in his fight against modernism—a love for the truth that was willing to endure opposition and hardship for the sake of protecting the faith. It is the love that motivates Traditional Catholics to continue attending the Traditional Latin Mass, even when it is difficult to do so, and to raise their children in the faith, despite the challenges posed by modern society.

Fr. Gabriel of St. Mary Magdalene, in his spiritual classic Divine Intimacy, reflects on the relationship between suffering and love. He writes, “Love transforms suffering into a redemptive act, uniting us more closely with Christ and drawing down graces upon the Church.” This is the key to navigating the modernist crisis: allowing our love for Christ and His Church to transform our sorrow into a redemptive offering. Just as the sorrows of the Blessed Virgin were united to the Passion of her Son, so too must our sorrows over the state of the Church be united to the Cross.

IV. The Role of Traditional Catholics: Bearing Witness to the Truth in Love
As Traditional Catholics, we are called to bear witness to the truth in love, even in the midst of the modernist crisis. This witness requires both courage and humility, as we seek to uphold the teachings of the Church while remaining charitable and compassionate toward those who may be caught up in the confusion of modernism.

The temptation in times of crisis is often to respond with anger or harshness, particularly when we see the sacred traditions of the Church being diminished or discarded. However, St. Paul reminds us that “love is patient and kind; love is not jealous or boastful; it is not arrogant or rude” (1 Corinthians 13:4-5). Our witness to the truth must always be marked by love, even when we are called to correct errors or defend the faith. As St. Thomas Aquinas teaches, “To love is to will the good of the other.” Our desire, even in the midst of conflict, must always be for the good of the Church and the salvation of souls.

St. Francis de Sales, a master of spiritual direction and a great example of charity in the face of opposition, wrote, “There is nothing so strong as gentleness, and nothing so gentle as real strength.” His words remind us that, even as we defend the truth, we must do so with gentleness and love, recognizing that it is only through love that hearts are truly converted.

V. Remaining Steadfast in the Faith
One of the greatest challenges for Traditional Catholics during the modernist crisis is the temptation to compromise on the truth in order to fit in with the prevailing culture or to avoid conflict. Yet, as Catholics, we are called to remain steadfast in the truth, even when it is unpopular or countercultural. The Church’s teachings on faith and morals are not subject to change or negotiation; they are rooted in divine revelation and must be upheld with fidelity.

Pope Benedict XVI, a strong advocate for the renewal of the Church’s liturgical and doctrinal traditions, frequently reminded the faithful that “truth is not determined by a majority vote.” In a world where truth is often relativized and where the pressures to conform to secular values are strong, we must have the courage to stand firm in the faith, knowing that the truth will ultimately prevail.

Fr. Leonard Goffine, in his Explanation of the Epistles and Gospels, writes about the importance of clinging to tradition in times of crisis. “When the storms of heresy and error threaten to overwhelm the Church,” he writes, “the faithful must cling more firmly to the rock of tradition, knowing that the truths of the faith will endure, even when the world seeks to destroy them.” This is the task of Traditional Catholics today: to remain steadfast in the faith, upholding the Church’s teachings on the sacraments, the liturgy, and moral theology, even in the face of widespread confusion and dissent.

VI. The Sacred Liturgy: A Source of Strength and Consolation
For Traditional Catholics, the Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) is not simply a preference or an aesthetic choice; it is a vital source of strength and consolation in the face of the modernist crisis. The TLM, with its emphasis on reverence, transcendence, and the unchanging nature of the divine mysteries, stands as a powerful witness to the continuity of the Church’s tradition and the eternal truths of the faith.

Pope Benedict XVI, in his letter Summorum Pontificum (2007), affirmed that the Traditional Latin Mass “must be given due honor for its venerable and ancient usage.” He recognized that the preservation of this liturgical form is not only important for those who feel attached to it but also for the entire Church, as it serves as a reminder of the sacredness and mystery of the Eucharist.

The beauty and reverence of the Traditional Latin Mass provide a much-needed antidote to the liturgical abuses and irreverence that have crept into some celebrations of the Novus Ordo Mass. In the TLM, the faithful encounter the timeless truths of the faith, expressed not only in words but in gestures, symbols, and music that elevate the soul to God. The silence, the Latin language, the solemnity of the priest’s actions—all of these elements draw the worshiper into the mystery of Christ’s sacrifice and remind us that the liturgy is not about us, but about God.

For Traditional Catholics, attending the TLM is not merely a personal preference; it is a way of remaining grounded in the faith, especially in times of trial. It is a means of encountering Christ in the Holy Eucharist with the reverence and devotion that He deserves, and it is a powerful witness to the beauty and continuity of the Church’s tradition.

VII. The Role of the Blessed Virgin Mary in Times of Crisis
In times of crisis, the Blessed Virgin Mary stands as a beacon of hope and consolation for the Church. As the Mother of the Church and the Mother of Sorrows, she understands the pain and suffering of her children and intercedes for them with her Son. Throughout history, Mary has appeared to warn, console, and guide the Church in times of trial, from her apparitions at Guadalupe, Lourdes, and Fatima to her role in the triumph of the Counter-Reformation.

St. Louis de Montfort, in his True Devotion to Mary, reminds us that “Mary is the safest, easiest, shortest, and most perfect way of approaching Jesus.” In times of sorrow and confusion, we are called to place our trust in the Immaculate Heart of Mary, knowing that she will lead us to her Son. As the Mother of Sorrows, she knows the depths of human suffering, having endured the Passion and Death of her Son, and she stands with us in our own moments of sorrow.

Fr. Gabriel of St. Mary Magdalene writes, “When we suffer, we are closest to Mary, for she too suffered greatly at the foot of the Cross.” In times of crisis, let us turn to her, asking for her intercession and her maternal protection. Let us pray the Rosary daily, offering it for the purification of the Church and the conversion of those who have fallen into error.

VIII. Practical Steps for Living Dolor et Amor
In light of the modernist crisis, how can Traditional Catholics practically live out the theme of Dolor et Amor—sorrow and love? Here are a few steps to guide us:

1. Deepen Your Relationship with Christ
   In times of crisis, it is essential to remain close to Christ. This means deepening your prayer life, especially through the Rosary, Eucharistic Adoration, and meditation on the Passion of Christ. It also means frequenting the sacraments, particularly the Eucharist and Confession.
2. Be Rooted in the Teachings of the Church
   Study the Catechism, the writings of the Church Fathers, and the documents of the Magisterium. Equip yourself with the knowledge of the faith so that you can discern the errors of modernism and defend the truth.
3. Attend the Traditional Latin Mass
   If possible, attend the Traditional Latin Mass regularly. The beauty, reverence, and continuity of this liturgy provide a much-needed refuge in times of confusion and doubt. The Mass is the source and summit of our faith, and it is in the Mass that we encounter Christ most fully.
4. Pray for the Church
   The modernist crisis is not something that will be resolved overnight. It will require prayer, sacrifice, and patience. Offer your sufferings for the sanctification of the Church and the conversion of those who are leading others astray. Pray for the clergy, that they may be faithful to their vocation and to the truth.
5. Be a Witness of Charity
   In all things, let your witness to the truth be marked by love. Love for Christ, love for the Church, and love for those who have fallen into error. Speak the truth with clarity and courage, but always with charity and humility.

IX. The Promise of Resurrection: Hope in the Midst of Sorrow
While the modernist crisis brings with it great sorrow, we must never lose sight of the hope that is ours in Christ. Just as Christ’s Passion was followed by His Resurrection, so too will the Church rise from this time of trial. As Dom Prosper Guéranger reminds us, “The Church, like her divine Spouse, must pass through the Passion in order to enter into glory.” The sorrows we endure now are but a prelude to the triumph of truth.

Pope Benedict XVI, in his reflections on the state of the Church, once said, “The Church will become small, but she will be more faithful to her essence.” This is the hope that we hold onto—that through this crisis, the Church will be purified and renewed, and that the truth will shine more brightly than ever before.

Conclusion: Persevering in Sorrow and Love
In conclusion, while the modernist crisis in the Church brings great sorrow to the hearts of the faithful, it also presents an opportunity for deepened love. Sorrow and love (Dolor et Amor) are inseparable in the life of a Catholic. Just as Mary stood at the foot of the Cross, uniting her sorrows with the love of Christ, so too are we called to stand firm in love and truth, even in the face of confusion and suffering.

The victory belongs to Christ, and He will never abandon His Church. As we remain steadfast in faith, let us always remember that sorrow, when transformed by love, becomes redemptive. Let us place our trust in the Sacred Heart of Jesus and the Immaculate Heart of Mary, knowing that, in the end, their hearts will triumph.

May Our Lady of Sorrows, who endured the greatest sorrow out of love for her Son and for us, intercede for the Church and for all of us as we navigate these difficult times. Deo gratias.

---

---

Spiritual Reflection for the Seventeenth Sunday Post Pentecost in the Traditional Latin Rite

The liturgy for the Seventeenth Sunday Post Pentecost in the Traditional Latin Rite offers us a rich opportunity to reflect on the essential commandments of love—love of God and love of neighbor—and how these two great commandments must guide our entire Christian life. The Gospel reading for today, from Matthew 22:34-46, provides the foundation for this reflection, as Jesus distills the Law and the Prophets into these two inseparable commandments. The Epistle, from Ephesians 4:1-6, complements this Gospel by calling us to live a life worthy of our Christian calling, marked by unity, humility, and peace.

The Greatest Commandments: Love of God and Love of Neighbor
In the Gospel, a Pharisee asks Jesus, “Master, which is the greatest commandment in the Law?” Jesus responds with the words that are central to the entire Christian life: “Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with thy whole heart, and with thy whole soul, and with thy whole mind. This is the greatest and the first commandment. And the second is like to this: Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself.”

These words of Our Lord echo the teachings of the Old Testament, particularly Deuteronomy 6:5 and Leviticus 19:18. Jesus, in His wisdom, does not merely add a new teaching but fulfills and deepens the Law by showing that the essence of the commandments lies in love—love for God and love for neighbor. These two commandments are not separate but intricately intertwined. One cannot love God without loving one’s neighbor, and one cannot truly love one’s neighbor without loving God.

The Primacy of Love
The command to love God with our whole heart, soul, and mind speaks to the totality of our being. Love of God must permeate every aspect of our lives—our thoughts, desires, actions, and intentions. St. Augustine once said, “Love God, and do what you will,” meaning that if we truly love God with all our heart, our actions will naturally flow from that love and will be in accordance with His will.

However, this love of God is not merely an internal feeling or an abstract idea. It must manifest in how we live, how we treat others, and how we approach our responsibilities in this world. Love of God compels us to prayer, to worship, and to seek His will in everything we do. It calls us to put God first in our lives, to renounce any idols or distractions that pull us away from Him, and to embrace the sacramental life that He offers us through His Church.

The second commandment, to love our neighbor as ourselves, is the natural outgrowth of the first. When we love God, we begin to see others as He sees them. We begin to love our neighbor not out of mere obligation but because we see in them the image of God. True Christian love of neighbor is not based on emotions or preferences but is rooted in the dignity of every person as a child of God. It is a love that seeks the good of the other, that desires their spiritual and temporal well-being, and that reflects the love that Christ has for us.

A Call to Holiness: Living Worthy of Our Calling
The Epistle for today, from St. Paul’s Letter to the Ephesians, echoes the message of the Gospel by reminding us that our love for God and neighbor must shape the way we live. St. Paul urges us to “walk worthy of the vocation in which you are called, with all humility and mildness, with patience, supporting one another in charity.” These words are a call to live out our Christian vocation with integrity and humility, always seeking unity and peace in the Body of Christ.

Humility is essential in our journey toward holiness. Without humility, we cannot truly love God or our neighbor. It is pride that leads us to focus on ourselves, to seek our own will rather than God’s, and to place our needs above those of others. Humility, on the other hand, allows us to recognize our dependence on God and our duty to serve others with selfless love.

St. Paul also speaks of patience and forbearance, virtues that are necessary in our relationships with others. The call to love our neighbor is not always easy, especially when we encounter difficulties, misunderstandings, or conflicts. But patience, rooted in love, allows us to bear with one another’s weaknesses and to seek reconciliation and peace. St. Paul’s exhortation to “keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace” reminds us that true love of neighbor seeks unity, not division, and strives for peace in all circumstances.

The Unity of Love in the Church
St. Paul also speaks of the unity of the Church, the Body of Christ. “One Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is above all, and through all, and in us all.” This unity is not merely an external reality but is rooted in the love that binds us together as members of Christ’s Body. The love of God that we are called to live out is a unifying force, drawing us closer to one another as we grow closer to Him.

In our current world, where division and discord seem to reign, this call to unity is more urgent than ever. The love of God and love of neighbor that Jesus speaks of in the Gospel is the antidote to the fragmentation we see in society and even within the Church. It is this love that has the power to heal wounds, to bring reconciliation, and to restore peace. We are called to be instruments of this love, beginning in our own families, our parishes, and our communities.

Sorrow and Love in the Christian Life
The theme of “sorrow and love,” which is often reflected upon during the Seventeenth Sunday Post Pentecost, is also a central theme of the Christian life. We are called to love in the midst of a world filled with sorrow. The sorrow of sin, suffering, and division is a reality that we cannot ignore. Yet, the Christian response to sorrow is love—a love that is willing to bear suffering for the sake of others, a love that is rooted in the Cross of Christ.

Our Lady of Sorrows, whose feast we recently celebrated, exemplifies this union of sorrow and love. She stood at the foot of the Cross, her heart pierced with sorrow as she witnessed the suffering and death of her Son. Yet, her sorrow was not devoid of hope or love. In her sorrow, she remained faithful to God’s will and offered her suffering in union with the redemptive sacrifice of Christ. Her example teaches us that, even in the face of sorrow, we are called to love—to love God with all our heart, soul, and mind, and to love our neighbor as ourselves.

Conclusion: The Path of Love
The Seventeenth Sunday Post Pentecost reminds us that love is the foundation of the Christian life. Love of God and love of neighbor are the two commandments that guide every aspect of our faith. As we reflect on the Gospel and the Epistle, we are called to examine our own lives: Are we loving God with our whole heart, soul, and mind? Are we loving our neighbor as ourselves? Are we walking worthy of the vocation to which we are called, with humility, patience, and charity?

Let us turn to the Sacred Heart of Jesus, the source of all love, and ask for the grace to love as He loves. Let us also turn to the Immaculate Heart of Mary, who teaches us how to love in the midst of sorrow, and ask for her intercession as we seek to grow in love for God and neighbor.

May we be strengthened in our resolve to live out the great commandments of love, and may we always seek to walk in the path of holiness, unity, and peace.

Discussion Questions

For Family Discussions:

1. In moments of difficulty or sorrow, how can we unite our suffering with the love of Christ and find peace? How has our family experienced this in the past?
2. How does the example of the Blessed Virgin Mary, especially in her sorrows, inspire us to handle our family struggles with faith and love?
3. The Gospel speaks of loving God with all our heart, soul, and mind. How can our family grow in this love for God, especially in challenging times?
4. How can we, as a family, comfort one another in moments of sorrow while showing love and trust in God’s plan?
5. What role does prayer, particularly the Rosary, play in helping our family unite sorrow and love?

For Catechism Classes:

1. Why is it important for Catholics to embrace both sorrow and love in their spiritual lives? How can we apply this in our own lives?
2. How does the commandment to love God with all our heart, soul, and mind help us to remain faithful even in times of personal or spiritual suffering?
3. In what ways does the modernist crisis in the Church reflect the challenges of uniting sorrow and love? How can we remain steadfast in our faith despite these challenges?
4. What does it mean to love God through suffering? How can we draw closer to Christ by embracing the Cross?
5. How can the liturgy, particularly the Traditional Latin Mass, help us deepen our understanding of Dolor et Amor (Sorrow and Love)?

For Sunday School:

1. How did Jesus show His love for us through His suffering? How can we imitate Him in our daily lives?
2. Why do you think Mary stayed at the foot of the Cross, even though she was filled with sorrow? What can we learn from her example?
3. When we face difficulties or sadness, how can we trust in God’s love for us? Can you think of a time when you felt God’s love in a difficult moment?
4. How can we show love to others when they are sad or going through hard times? How is this an act of love toward God?
5. How can we love God more in our daily lives, even when things don’t go as we expect?

For Youth Ministry:

1. In today’s world, many people struggle with feelings of sorrow, doubt, or confusion. How can the Catholic faith help us transform sorrow into love and hope?
2. How do we respond to suffering—both personal and in the Church—without falling into despair? What role does love play in how we handle difficult situations?
3. Why is it important to remain faithful to the teachings of the Church, even when it seems easier to follow the ways of the world? How does this relate to loving God with all our heart, soul, and mind?
4. How does the modernist crisis challenge young Catholics to stay rooted in tradition and truth? What practical steps can we take to remain steadfast?
5. In times of trial, how can we trust that God’s love is still present in our lives? What can we learn from saints who endured great sorrow and remained faithful?

For Personal Reflection:

1. What are some moments of sorrow in my life where I have felt the love of God transforming my pain? How can I grow in trusting His plan in future struggles?
2. The Gospel calls us to love God with all our heart, soul, and mind. In what areas of my life can I grow in this love, especially when faced with challenges?
3. How do I respond to the sorrows I see in the Church, particularly in the context of the modernist crisis? How can I respond with both sorrow and love, following the example of the saints?
4. How can I deepen my relationship with the Blessed Virgin Mary, especially by contemplating her sorrows? In what ways can her example inspire my own journey through suffering?
5. What practical ways can I unite my personal suffering with the love of Christ on the Cross, and how can this strengthen my faith and love for the Church?

By discussing these questions, we can deepen our understanding of the Gospel message, strengthen our commitment to living in truth, and find ways to compassionately engage with the world around us.

---

---

Dolor et Amor in Evangelism: Approaching Loved Ones and Family with the Gospel

The theme of “Sorrow and Love” is an essential aspect of Christian life, particularly when it comes to evangelizing family members, friends, and those who may not share the same Traditional Catholic views. In a world that often sees sorrow as a weakness and love as mere sentimentality, the Gospel offers a radically different vision: one in which sorrow, when united to love, becomes transformative, redemptive, and life-giving. This dynamic is especially poignant in evangelization, as it calls for both perseverance in suffering and a deep, sacrificial love for others.

When we think about evangelizing those close to us, the stakes feel incredibly high. The sorrow of seeing a loved one estranged from the Church or indifferent to its teachings can be overwhelming. At the same time, love compels us to reach out, to share the truth of the Gospel, and to witness to the transformative power of God’s grace. However, the manner in which we engage in this task is critical. Evangelizing friends, family members, or even non-Traditional Catholics cannot be a mere exercise in debate or doctrinal instruction; it must be rooted in deep love, patience, humility, and the willingness to bear the cross of sorrow that often accompanies such efforts.

The Magisterium of the Church, especially in the period before Vatican II, offers a wealth of insights into how Catholics are called to engage in evangelization. Pope Leo XIII’s encyclical Sapientiae Christianae emphasizes the duty of every Catholic to bear witness to the truth, stating, “It is the duty of all who live by the Gospel to spread the faith among those who are in error.” However, this duty must always be tempered by charity. St. Pius X, in his encyclical Acerbo Nimis, highlights the necessity of catechesis in evangelization, stressing that ignorance of the faith is often the root cause of indifference or opposition to it. Yet, even in this more doctrinally focused approach, St. Pius X insists that love must be the driving force behind any effort to instruct others in the faith.

Evangelizing through love

One of the central challenges in evangelizing those close to us is the emotional weight of the endeavor. When family members or friends reject the Church or seem indifferent to its teachings, the sorrow can be profound. It is important to remember, however, that this sorrow, when united with love, can become a powerful means of sanctification. In his reflections on Christian suffering, St. Alphonsus Liguori reminds us that sorrow, when offered to God, becomes a means of participating in the redemptive work of Christ. This is the model for evangelization: not merely to speak words of truth but to live a life of love and sacrifice, offering even our sorrows for the conversion of those we love.

This approach to evangelization is particularly relevant in our contemporary context, where many Catholics, even those raised in the faith, have drifted away from the traditional teachings and practices of the Church. The modern world often presents a distorted view of love, one that is detached from truth and reduced to mere emotional affirmation. As a result, many people today, including those within our own families, have difficulty understanding the relationship between love and truth, between compassion and moral integrity.

Here, we can look to contemporary Catholic evangelists and apologists, such as Scott Hahn and Peter Kreeft, who emphasize the importance of grounding our evangelization efforts in both love and truth. Hahn, in his book Rome Sweet Home, shares his personal journey of conversion and the role that patient, loving witness played in drawing him closer to the Church. He frequently stresses that effective evangelization requires more than intellectual arguments; it requires living the faith authentically, so that others are drawn not only by the truth of what we say but by the love and joy they see in our lives.

Similarly, Peter Kreeft, in his writings on evangelization, emphasizes that the truth of the Gospel must always be communicated with love. Kreeft argues that many people today are not persuaded by purely rational arguments but are deeply moved by witness—by seeing how the Gospel transforms lives. He points to the example of the early Christians, who, in the face of persecution and sorrow, continued to love their enemies and spread the Gospel through their actions as much as through their words.

Praxis

In practical terms, this means that evangelizing family and friends requires patience, humility, and a willingness to endure sorrow for the sake of love. It is not enough to simply present Catholic teaching in a way that wins arguments or refutes errors; we must also bear witness to the transforming power of Christ’s love in our own lives. This witness often requires enduring the pain of seeing a loved one reject the faith, while continuing to pray for them, love them, and remain open to the movement of the Holy Spirit in their lives.

One practical suggestion for evangelizing loved ones is to focus on building relationships of trust and openness. Rather than immediately engaging in theological debates or attempting to correct misunderstandings, it is often more effective to simply be present, to listen, and to share the faith through personal testimony and example. This approach is particularly important with family members, where past hurts or misunderstandings can often complicate discussions about faith. By showing patience and love, even in the face of disagreement, we can create an environment where the Holy Spirit can work in the hearts of those we are trying to reach.

Another important aspect of evangelization is prayer. St. Monica, the mother of St. Augustine, is a powerful example of how persistent prayer, combined with patient love, can lead to the conversion of even the most hardened hearts. Monica endured years of sorrow as she watched her son reject the faith and live a life of sin. Yet, through her constant prayers and loving witness, Augustine eventually returned to the Church and became one of its greatest saints. This model of prayerful perseverance is essential for anyone seeking to evangelize loved ones, especially those who may be indifferent or hostile to the faith.

In addition to personal prayer, it is important to involve others in prayer for the conversion of our loved ones. Many Catholic families and communities have adopted the practice of offering Masses, Rosaries, and other devotions for the conversion of family members. This communal aspect of prayer not only strengthens our own faith but also calls down graces upon those for whom we are praying. As Pope Leo XIII reminds us in Sapientiae Christianae, “Prayer is the first and foremost means by which we can draw down the grace of God upon those who are in error and lead them back to the truth.”

While prayer is essential, it must be accompanied by action. This means that we must live the faith in a way that is visible and attractive to others. St. Francis of Assisi is often quoted as saying, “Preach the Gospel at all times; when necessary, use words.” While the exact attribution of this quote is debated, the sentiment is clear: our actions, more than our words, are often the most powerful means of evangelization. This is particularly true in the context of family and close friendships, where people are more likely to be influenced by the way we live our faith than by what we say.

Living the faith authentically requires not only personal holiness but also a willingness to engage with the world in a spirit of charity and truth. This means being willing to speak the truth, even when it is difficult, but doing so in a way that is rooted in love. St. Paul’s exhortation in Ephesians 4:15 to “speak the truth in love” is especially relevant here. We must avoid both the extremes of harshness and indifference, finding the balance that allows us to present the truth of the Gospel in a way that is both clear and compassionate.

One area where this balance is particularly important is in addressing the moral teachings of the Church, especially those that are often seen as controversial or outdated by modern standards. Many Catholics today, including those within our own families, struggle with the Church’s teachings on issues such as marriage, sexuality, and the sanctity of life. In these cases, it is essential to approach the conversation with both clarity and compassion, always grounding our discussions in the love of Christ.

Dr. Edward Sri, a contemporary Catholic theologian, often speaks about the importance of engaging in these difficult conversations with humility and charity. In his book Who Am I to Judge?, Sri emphasizes that while we must never compromise on the truth, we must also recognize that people are often dealing with deep wounds and misunderstandings that require a gentle, loving approach. He encourages Catholics to adopt a posture of listening and understanding, rather than one of condemnation or judgment, trusting that the Holy Spirit will work in the hearts of those we are trying to reach.

In evangelizing family members or friends who have drifted away from the faith, it is also important to recognize that conversion is a process, not an event. This means that we must be patient and persistent, understanding that it may take time for someone to fully embrace the truth of the Gospel. We should not be discouraged if our initial efforts seem to bear little fruit. As St. Teresa of Calcutta often said, “God has not called me to be successful; He has called me to be faithful.” Our task is to continue sowing seeds of faith, trusting that God will bring about the harvest in His own time.

One practical way to foster this process of conversion is to invite loved ones to experience the beauty of the Church’s liturgy and sacraments. Many people who have fallen away from the Church have never truly experienced the richness of the Catholic tradition, particularly the reverence and beauty of the Traditional Latin Mass. By inviting family members or friends to attend Mass with us, we can open their hearts to the transcendent power of the liturgy, allowing them to encounter Christ in a profound and personal way.

At the same time, it is important to recognize that not everyone will respond immediately to such invitations. In these cases, we must remain patient and understand that evangelization is a journey that requires love, patience, and perseverance. For many people, conversion is a gradual process that takes time, prayer, and the witness of others. Through our daily actions, kindness, and steadfast faith, we can plant seeds of truth that may one day grow into a deeper commitment to the faith.

In this respect, inviting friends or family members to experience the beauty of the Church’s sacraments is a crucial step in the process of conversion. For many people, witnessing the reverence and beauty of the Traditional Latin Mass or participating in the quiet intimacy of Eucharistic Adoration can serve as a profound entry point into the mysteries of the faith. It is in these sacred moments that the Holy Spirit can work most powerfully to soften hearts and open minds to the truth of the Gospel.

Yet even if those we love do not immediately respond to these invitations, we must remain patient and faithful. St. Thérèse of Lisieux, the Little Flower, reminds us of the power of simple, hidden acts of love and sacrifice. Her “little way” of offering small sacrifices for the conversion of souls teaches us that evangelization does not always require grand gestures but can be as simple as offering up daily annoyances, disappointments, or sufferings for the salvation of others. In this way, our love and sorrow become intertwined, as we willingly embrace the crosses of our own lives and unite them with Christ’s redemptive suffering.

The Domestic Church

In addition to inviting loved ones to participate in the liturgy, it is important to create a home environment that reflects the love of Christ. The family, as the “domestic Church,” plays a critical role in evangelization, especially when it comes to children and young adults. By creating a home that is centered on prayer, the sacraments, and the love of God, parents can foster an environment where the seeds of faith can grow. This can be as simple as praying together as a family, having sacred images or statues in the home, and celebrating the liturgical seasons with meaningful traditions.

Parents, in particular, have a unique responsibility in evangelizing their children. In his encyclical Divini Illius Magistri, Pope Pius XI reminds us that parents are the primary educators of their children in the faith. This responsibility cannot be outsourced to the Church or Catholic schools; it must be lived out in the daily life of the family. The faith is not something that can be merely taught; it must be caught—through the example of parents who live their faith with joy, love, and integrity.

Converting the converted

Evangelizing non-Traditional Catholics, especially those who may have fallen away from the faith or who have adopted a more modernist approach to Catholicism, requires a delicate balance of truth and compassion. It is not enough to simply point out errors or inconsistencies in their beliefs; we must also show them the beauty and richness of the Church’s Tradition. This can be done through personal testimony, sharing resources such as books or articles, or inviting them to explore the treasures of the Church’s spiritual heritage.

Contemporary conservative Catholic theologians such as Ralph Martin and Dr. Janet Smith offer practical insights into how to engage with non-Traditional Catholics in a way that is both compassionate and faithful to the Church’s teachings. In his book Will Many Be Saved?, Ralph Martin emphasizes the importance of speaking the truth about salvation while also recognizing that many people today have been misled by false teachings or a watered-down version of the faith. He calls for a renewed commitment to evangelization, grounded in the Church’s authentic teaching on sin, repentance, and the necessity of conversion.

Dr. Janet Smith, a well-known Catholic ethicist, has written extensively on the Church’s teachings on sexuality, marriage, and family life. Her approach to evangelizing those who may struggle with these teachings is marked by both clarity and compassion. She encourages Catholics to engage in respectful dialogue, always grounding their arguments in the natural law and the Church’s consistent teaching, while also acknowledging the personal struggles that many people face in these areas. By presenting the Church’s teachings in a way that is both truthful and compassionate, we can help others see the wisdom and beauty of the Church’s moral doctrine.

Patience and humility

Ultimately, evangelizing family members, friends, and non-Traditional Catholics is a long and often challenging process. It requires not only knowledge of the faith but also deep love, patience, and the willingness to endure sorrow for the sake of others. We must be willing to bear the pain of seeing those we love reject the faith, while continuing to pray for them, love them, and remain open to the Holy Spirit’s work in their lives.

Pope Pius XII, in his encyclical Mystici Corporis Christi, reminds us that the Church is the mystical body of Christ, and as members of this body, we are called to participate in the redemptive mission of Christ. This mission includes not only proclaiming the Gospel but also offering our own sufferings in union with Christ for the salvation of souls. As we evangelize those around us, we must remember that our sorrow is not wasted; it is a participation in the redemptive suffering of Christ, and it has the power to bring about the conversion of hearts.

In conclusion, the theme of “Sorrow and Love” in evangelization is a call to embrace the crosses of our own lives, to love those who may be far from the Church, and to trust in the transforming power of God’s grace. Evangelizing family members, friends, and non-Traditional Catholics requires patience, humility, and a deep commitment to the truth of the Gospel. It is a journey that often involves sorrow, but it is also a journey that is rooted in love—a love that seeks the ultimate good of those we are called to evangelize: their salvation in Christ.

---

Life in the Spirit: Dolor et Amor

The Christian life in the Spirit is one of paradox: a life in which sorrow (dolor) and love (amor) are intimately intertwined, each enriching and giving meaning to the other. To live in the Spirit is to embrace the reality that love and suffering are inseparable in the journey toward God. This truth is exemplified most perfectly in the life of Christ, whose Passion—His ultimate act of love—was born from intense sorrow and suffering. His life, death, and resurrection reveal that love is not merely a feeling but a willing of the good of another, even at great personal cost.

The Holy Spirit, who dwells in the hearts of believers, invites us into this divine mystery of dolor et amor, calling us to participate in the redemptive work of Christ through our own sufferings and sacrifices. When we embrace the crosses that come our way with love, they become not burdens but vehicles of grace, transforming us more fully into the likeness of Christ.

Mary, the Mother of Sorrows, offers a perfect example of this union between sorrow and love. Her heart was pierced with sorrow as she witnessed her Son’s suffering, yet her love for God remained unwavering. In her, we see the call to remain faithful in the midst of suffering, trusting that love transforms sorrow into a means of grace and salvation.

In our daily lives, living in the Spirit means accepting the trials and sorrows that come our way, not with resignation, but with love. It means offering our sufferings to God as acts of love for Him and for others. This is the essence of Christian life: to unite our dolor with the amor of Christ, trusting that through the Holy Spirit, even our sorrows can bear fruit for the Kingdom of God.

As we grow in the life of the Spirit, we learn that love and sorrow are not opposites but complementary realities. The more we love, the more we will suffer, not in despair, but in a spirit of hope and trust that God’s love will bring good from every sorrow.

---

A Sermon for Sunday: Revd Dr Robert Wilson

Seven Sorrows of the Blessed Virgin Mary/Octave of the Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Mary/Seventeenth Sunday after Pentecost

Today is the feast of the Seven Sorrows of the Blessed Virgin Mary, as well as the Octave of her Nativity. We are also commemorating the Seventeenth Sunday after Pentecost. Today’s feast, the Seven Sorrows, shows Mary not only as the theotokos, the God bearer, but also as the Mater Dolorosa, the Mother of Sorrows. Yesterday we celebrated the Exaltation of the Holy Cross, and we sang the great hymns of Christ’s triumph over the powers of sin and death on the cross. Today we focus more on the pathos of the scene, a theme especially developed in the medieval Western Church, as we sing the Stabat Mater

At the Cross her Station keeping
Stood the mournful mother weeping
Close to Jesus at the last.

Today’s Gospel of the scene at the foot of the cross of Jesus is one of the most poignant in the Gospels. Christ entrusts his mother to the care of St. John, the beloved disciple. “Woman, behold thy son. Son, behold thy mother.”

God in Christ came into the world to suffer and to die, though being in the form of God, he made himself of no reputation and humbled himself to death on the cross. He came as one without form and comeliness, a man of sorrows and acquainted with grief. Though his mother was chosen to be the bearer of the Word made flesh, she was also chosen to be the mother of sorrows. At the Presentation of Christ in the Temple the aged Simeon foresaw that a sword would pierce her own heart also. This was fulfilled when she witnessed his suffering at the foot of the cross.

It is a reminder that love is inseparable from suffering. C. S. Lewis said that we can either remain detached and uninvolved or we can love and be involved, and that will involve suffering. This contrasts with the ancient Stoics who prided themselves on viewing the world with indifference to the world of pain and suffering. Likewise, the classic images of the Buddha show a figure serene and detached from this world, for to attain nirvana is to cease to care about the pain and suffering of human life. By contrast, the message of the Cross is one of redemption through suffering, a message very different from the impassive serenity of the Buddha. St. John in his epistle speaks of Christ who came by water and by blood, the blood and water that flowed from his side pierced by the soldiers at the crucifixion. The Risen Christ who appeared to the apostle Thomas still bore the scars of the crucifixion on his glorified and resurrected body. Our hope is in the resurrection of the body and the ultimate healing of our own wounds, not the dissolution of our personalities into some impersonal absolute.

Meditation on the sufferings of the Passion of Christ and the Seven Sorrows of Mary is a type of spirituality that is very attractive to some minds, though it is repellent to others. It is associated with the transition that historians of Christian art and iconography have observed to take place in the medieval period between the earlier representation of Christ on the Cross as alive with open eyes to the more realistic later images of Christ on the cross as dead with closed eyes. The Stations of the Cross were developed and popularised by the Franciscans, while meditation on the Seven Sorrows of Mary was the particular charism of the Servites. For some this represents a falling away from earlier and more symbolic iconography, for others it marks a positive development of greater realism in Christian art. It is essentially a medieval and western development, though it is not to be dismissed simply because it is medieval and western.

It is a theme that is especially associated with St. Bernard of Clairvaux in the twelfth century. Commenting on today’s Gospel he stated: “The martyrdom of the Virgin is set before us, not only in the prophecy of Simeon, but also in the story itself of the Lord’s Passion…. Even so, O Blessed Mother! The sword did indeed pierce through thy soul! For nought could pierce the Body of thy Son, nor pierce thy soul likewise. Yea, and when this Jesus of thine had given up the ghost, and the bloody spear could torture him no more, thy soul winced as it pierced his dead side- his own soul might leave him, but thine could not. The sword of sorrow pierced through thy soul, so that we may truly call thee more than martyr, in whom the love, that made thee suffer along with thy Son, wrung thy heart more bitterly than any pang of bodily pain could do. Did not that word of his indeed pierce through thy soul, sharper than any two edged sword, even to the dividing asunder of soul and spirit, – “Woman, behold thy son”. O what a charge to thee! Thou art given John for Jesus, the servant for his Lord, the disciple for his Master, the son of Zebedee for the Son of God, a mere man for Very God. O how keenly must the hearing of those words have pierced through thy loving soul, when even our hearts, stony, iron as they are, are wrung at the memory thereof only! Marvel not, my brethren, that Mary should be called a martyr in spirit. He indeed may marvel who remembereth not what Paul saith, naming the greater sins of the Gentiles, that they were “without natural affection”. Far other were the bowels of Mary, and far other may those of her servants be! But some men perchance will say: Did she not know that he was to die? Yea, without doubt she knew it. Did she not hope that he was soon to rise again? Yea, she most faithfully hoped it. And did she still mourn because he was crucified? Yea, bitterly. But who art thou, my brother, or whence hast thou such wisdom, to marvel less that the Son of Mary suffered than that Mary suffered with him? He could die with the body, and could she not die with him in her heart? His was the deed of that love, greater than which hath no man, her’s, of a love, like to which hath no man, save he.”

Hence, while it is true that meditations on the Passion of Christ and the Seven Sorrows of his Mother has sometimes been associated with an unhealthy obsession with suffering, when properly understood it does point to the central doctrine of our faith, that of redemption through suffering. It is this that distinguishes the Christian faith from other religions. The teachings of the Buddha or Confucius give good advice, but not good news. Mohammed claimed that authority of a prophet, but not that of a Saviour who brings redemption through suffering. By contrast, the Christian faith gives not only good advice, but good news, the good news of redemption through the life, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ.

O God, at whose suffering the prophecy of Simeon was fulfilled, and a sword of sorrow pierced through the gentle soul of the glorious Virgin and Mother Mary, mercifully grant that we who speak worshipfully of her woes, may obtain the saving purchase of thy suffering.

---

---

---

Feasts this week

September 15: The Seven Sorrows of the Blessed Virgin Mary: This feast focuses on the deep sorrow experienced by Mary throughout her life, particularly during the Passion and Crucifixion of her Son. It invites the faithful to meditate on seven key moments of sorrow in Mary’s life, such as the prophecy of Simeon, the flight into Egypt, and standing at the foot of the Cross. Through her immense suffering, Mary becomes the Mater Dolorosa (Mother of Sorrows), offering a model of how to unite human suffering with love and trust in God’s will. The feast calls us to emulate her in carrying our crosses with patience and courage, trusting in the redeeming power of suffering when offered to God.

September 16: St. Cornelius and St. Cyprian, Martyrs: This joint feast commemorates two early Church leaders who stood firm in the faith during a time of intense persecution. St. Cornelius, Pope from 251 to 253, defended the Church’s teaching on the reconciliation of lapsed Christians who had renounced the faith during persecution. St. Cyprian, Bishop of Carthage, supported Cornelius and argued for unity in the Church. Both were martyred for their faith: Cornelius was exiled and died in hardship, while Cyprian was beheaded. This feast celebrates their witness to unity, courage, and forgiveness in the face of trial.

September 17: The Impression of the Stigmata of St. Francis: This feast honors the mystical event in 1224 when St. Francis of Assisi received the stigmata, the wounds of Christ’s Passion, on his body while praying on Mount La Verna. It was a sign of his profound union with Christ’s suffering and love. St. Francis, already renowned for his life of poverty, humility, and service to the poor, became a living image of Christ crucified. The feast reminds the faithful of the call to imitate Christ in both His love and His suffering, accepting hardships as part of a deeper union with God.

September 18: St. Joseph of Cupertino: St. Joseph of Cupertino, a 17th-century Franciscan friar, is known for his deep spirituality and miraculous levitations during prayer. Despite his limited intellectual abilities, Joseph’s humble obedience and love for God earned him great spiritual insights. His life was a testimony to the fact that holiness does not depend on intellectual brilliance but on a simple, pure heart. St. Joseph is particularly revered as the patron of students and those facing examinations, as his life illustrates how God can use even the most humble souls for His glory.

September 19: St. Januarius and Companions, Martyrs: St. Januarius, Bishop of Benevento, was martyred in 305 AD during Diocletian’s persecution of Christians. He is famous for the miracle of the liquefaction of his blood, which occurs three times a year in Naples, where his relics are kept. Along with his companions, St. Januarius courageously faced martyrdom, enduring death by beheading for his refusal to renounce his Christian faith. This feast day invites Catholics to reflect on the enduring power of faith and the miraculous signs God gives to confirm His saints.

September 20: St. Eustace and Companions, Martyrs: St. Eustace, a Roman general under Emperor Trajan, experienced a dramatic conversion to Christianity after seeing a vision of a crucifix between the antlers of a stag. He and his family were eventually martyred for their faith. This feast day recalls the powerful witness of early Christians who, despite their social status or former life, were willing to embrace the Christian faith even unto death. Eustace’s story speaks to the transformative power of grace and the call to remain faithful to Christ in the face of trials.

September 21: St. Matthew, Apostle and Evangelist: The feast of St. Matthew celebrates the Apostle and Evangelist who was called by Jesus from his former life as a tax collector to become a disciple. Matthew’s conversion is a testament to the boundless mercy of Christ, who calls even the most unlikely individuals to follow Him. As the author of the first Gospel, St. Matthew is remembered for his detailed account of Christ’s life and teachings, particularly focusing on Jesus as the fulfillment of Old Testament prophecies. His feast day encourages the faithful to respond to Christ’s call with generosity and zeal, regardless of past shortcomings.

---

September Embertide: Its Importance for Traditional Catholics

September Embertide, part of the quarterly Ember Days, holds a special place in the Traditional Catholic calendar. These days—Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday after the Feast of the Exaltation of the Holy Cross (September 14)—are dedicated to fasting, prayer, and penance, a tradition with ancient roots. The Ember Days originated as a means of sanctifying the changing seasons, thanking God for the harvest, and seeking His blessings on future crops. For Traditional Catholics, September Embertide is a profound opportunity to reconnect with the rhythms of creation and the Church’s liturgical seasons, and to practice spiritual discipline through fasting and prayer.

Historical Roots and Purpose of Ember Days

The Ember Days date back to the early centuries of the Church, particularly in Rome, where the faithful would observe them at the turning points of the four seasons: spring, summer, fall, and winter. Each set of Ember Days marks a time to pray for the sanctification of clergy, for the natural world, and for personal purification. Traditionally, they also included special Masses and ordinations, linking the spiritual and physical realms. In September, these Ember Days coincide with the harvest season, when Catholics would give thanks for the fruits of the earth and seek divine protection for future growth.

A Call to Prayer and Fasting

One of the key aspects of Embertide is the call to fasting and abstinence. Traditional Catholics observe these days with a heightened sense of devotion, abstaining from meat and limiting meals to one full meal and two smaller ones, similar to Lenten practices. Fasting not only purifies the body but is a spiritual offering, uniting the faithful to Christ’s sacrifice. It is a reminder that true Christian life is one of self-denial, discipline, and reliance on God’s grace.

In addition to fasting, Embertide is a time of increased prayer. The Church, particularly through the Traditional Latin Mass, encourages the faithful to attend Mass and receive the sacraments during these days. The prayers of the Ember Days often reflect themes of repentance, gratitude for the earth’s bounty, and intercession for the clergy. Traditional Catholics often use this time to meditate on the interconnectedness of God’s creation, their own spiritual journey, and the mission of the Church.

A Time for Gratitude and Reflection on Creation

September Embertide, falling during the harvest season, is particularly focused on gratitude for the fruits of the earth. The Church encourages the faithful to reflect on the gifts of creation, thanking God for the food and resources provided by the earth. It is also a time to consider the responsibility humans have as stewards of creation. Traditional Catholics often see this as an opportunity to renew their commitment to living in harmony with nature, understanding that the blessings of the earth are a reflection of God’s providence and care for humanity.

Spiritual Renewal and the Church’s Mission

For Traditional Catholics, September Embertide is not only a time to focus on personal purification but also on the broader mission of the Church. The Ember Days were traditionally linked to the ordination of clergy, with special prayers offered for priests and religious. This connection reminds the faithful that the Church’s mission to evangelize and serve the world requires holy, well-formed leaders. During these days, Traditional Catholics are encouraged to pray for the sanctification of priests, the raising up of new vocations, and the guidance of the Holy Spirit in the Church’s work.

In a broader sense, Embertide represents a return to simplicity and the natural rhythms of life. By fasting and observing these days of prayer, Catholics realign themselves with the Church’s liturgical year, marking time not by secular calendars but by the sacred cycle of penance, fasting, and renewal. In an increasingly fast-paced and disconnected world, Embertide provides a moment to pause, reflect, and refocus on the spiritual life.

Conclusion

September Embertide is a powerful tradition for Traditional Catholics, blending the elements of fasting, prayer, gratitude, and reflection on the Church’s mission. These days offer an opportunity to deepen one’s relationship with God through penitential practices and a renewed awareness of the gifts of creation. At a time when many are far removed from the rhythms of nature and the Church’s ancient customs, September Embertide invites the faithful to slow down, to give thanks, and to seek spiritual renewal through the timeless practices of the Catholic faith.

---

Finding Light Amidst the Darkness: A Call to Faith and Resilience

In recent times, many believers are expressing their despair on social media, reflecting a profound theological and spiritual crisis. This article seeks to address these concerns and offer a path forward grounded in faith and resilience. In both the Church and the world at large, there is no shortage of evil and reasons for despondency. Political trends often oppose divine and natural law, and many of our spiritual leaders seem either inactive, complicit, or wholly misguided. The question we must confront is: How do we handle this negativity? Do we confront it with the power of Jesus’ name, or do we allow it to consume us, taking root like a destructive cancer?

A pertinent analogy can be drawn from Denethor in The Lord of the Rings. He gazed into the Palantir and saw only the inevitable defeat of good and the triumph of evil, falling into despair—just as the enemy intended. This scenario mirrors how many today perceive the Church and the world. Reflecting on this, the words from the Gospel of St John (12:35-36) during a recent traditional rite Mass come to mind: “Yet a little while the light is among you. Walk while you have the light, that darkness may not overtake you.” Even in times of deep darkness, we know where to find the light. Jesus implies that those who believe in the light become light themselves, a beacon in the darkness like a mighty Paschal candle.

Catholicism is fundamentally about union with Christ. The Church exists to facilitate this union, offering life from the Life and light from the Light. Despite corruption within the Church’s hierarchy at various points in history, the Church has endured through God’s grace, with Christ remaining ever-present among us. The Byzantine tradition reminds us, “Christ is among us! He is and ever shall be!” This abiding presence has always led to periods of renewal, often ignited by faithful reformers. Even though major changes often occur slowly, it is the fidelity of the faithful during the darkest times that carries the Church forward.

Currently, many voices argue that the Church faces an unprecedented crisis, worse than historical challenges like the Arian crisis or the Protestant Reformation. Some believe the Papacy is vacant or that recovery is impossible. Tradition-loving Catholics often feel marginalized and powerless. However, we must reject the notion that Satan has cornered God. At the end of the day, there are two alternatives: faith or nihilism. For the thinking individual, life’s purpose is to become a saint or to die trying. This conviction echoes Pascal’s Wager, choosing the promise of eternal life with Christ over the emptiness of worldly gains.

Historically, saints endured massive trials, often experiencing profound spiritual darkness. Their perseverance, even when they couldn’t see through the fog of despair, is what made them saints. This perseverance is a testament to their faith in God’s ultimate victory over evil. As St. John of the Cross wrote, “In the dark night of the soul, bright flows the river of God.” This sentiment reflects the profound spiritual truth that in our darkest moments, God’s grace shines brightest, guiding us through the night. St. Augustine also reminds us of the enduring presence of Christ in the Church: “The Church wavers not, though tempests beat against her; though the elements rage, she sinks not; because she is founded upon a rock, and the rock is Christ.”

Moreover, the words of St. Teresa of Avila offer encouragement: “Let nothing disturb you, let nothing frighten you. All things are passing; God never changes. Patience obtains all things. He who has God finds he lacks nothing; God alone suffices.” Pope Pius XII in his encyclical Mystici Corporis Christi stated, “The Church, the mystical Body of Christ, is an extension of the Incarnation. As Christ is divine, so the Church shares in this divinity and is safeguarded from error in faith and morals.” Pope Leo XIII, in his encyclical Rerum Novarum, emphasized the enduring nature of the Church amidst societal upheavals: “The Church of Christ is the true and sole teacher of virtue and guardian of morals. She is always, and in all places, the same; her authority extends to all times and to all places.” St. Cyprian of Carthage once said, “No one can have God as his Father who does not have the Church as his Mother.” This underscores the essential role of the Church in our spiritual lives, even amid its imperfections.

We are not immune to trials and crises, especially those who lead or are serious about discipleship. The question we must ask ourselves is whether we are nourishing our faith. As a priest once said, “Faith is like a muscle: it grows stronger when you exercise it, and weaker when you don’t.” A practical way to nourish faith is by reading the Gospels daily, getting to know Christ better. The transformative power of Scripture and prayer cannot be overstated; they provide the strength to see through life’s trials and the certainty that the world’s evils are temporary and conquerable.

In conclusion, we must support one another in faith, increasing our prayer and trust in God’s promises. Let us seek strength from the Sacred Heart of Jesus, fostering a community of love and resilience amidst the challenges of our age. Let us recall the words of St. Paul, who faced countless trials but remained steadfast: “I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me” (Philippians 4:13). This declaration of faith is our rallying cry, reminding us that, with Christ, we have the power to endure and overcome. By holding fast to our faith, we not only survive these challenging times but also become beacons of hope and light for others, leading them towards the ultimate truth and love found in Christ.

---

CURRENT AFFAIRS

---

A Cold Winter Ahead: UK Government’s Controversial Cuts to the Winter Fuel Allowance and the Impact on Pensioners

Labour’s recent changes to the Winter Fuel Allowance, which restrict the payments to only those pensioners on means-tested benefits such as Pension Credit, have generated significant debate and concern. The move will drastically reduce the number of eligible recipients from around 10.8 million pensioners last year to a smaller subset who qualify for benefits like Pension Credit. This decision, announced as part of the government’s broader effort to address a £22 billion deficit in public finances, has been defended by Labour leadership as a necessary step to ensure fiscal responsibility and to target resources more effectively at those most in need.

The Winter Fuel Payment has long been a universal benefit aimed at helping older people afford heating during the colder months. Critics of the new means-testing argue that it introduces a “cliff edge,” where pensioners just above the threshold for benefits lose support, leaving many facing a stark “heat or eat” dilemma this winter. This issue is compounded by the fact that around 880,000 pensioners eligible for Pension Credit do not claim it, which means they could also miss out on the Winter Fuel Payment under the new rules.

Commentators have raised alarms about the potential consequences. The Trades Union Congress has warned that this austerity measure could worsen poverty among pensioners, particularly in light of rising energy costs. Additionally, Labour MPs like John McDonnell and Kim Johnson have criticized the lack of transparency, as the government has refused to publish an impact assessment before voting on the measure, sparking fears that many pensioners will fall into fuel poverty.

The ramifications of this policy are particularly concerning given the vulnerable position of many older people, who face increased risks during cold winters. Charities working with the elderly, such as Age UK, have expressed concern that the cuts could push many pensioners into financial hardship. With energy prices rising and the cost of living crisis continuing, these cuts are likely to hit the most vulnerable older people hardest.

Despite the significant changes, no formal review was conducted to evaluate how this policy might affect vulnerable populations, particularly the elderly, who rely on this support to heat their homes during colder months. This omission has raised concerns among advocacy groups and some MPs, who argue that such an analysis is essential for understanding the broader social and economic implications of the cut, especially in the context of rising energy costs.

Without an impact assessment, it’s difficult to determine the full consequences of the policy on pensioners’ health, well-being, and financial stability, making it a contentious decision that could deepen the challenges faced by those already struggling with fuel poverty.

Labour’s defense, spearheaded by Chancellor Rachel Reeves, is that these changes are a tough but necessary measure to stabilize the economy while ensuring that pensioners most in need retain support. However, the opposition within Labour and from advocacy groups highlights the deep concerns about the social impact of these cuts, especially for those on the margins of eligibility.

In sum, while the government’s rationale focuses on fiscal responsibility, the social costs for many older people could be profound, potentially leading to increased fuel poverty and heightened risks to health and well-being for those who lose this vital support.

Sources

• Politico: Discusses Labour’s internal divisions over the Winter Fuel Payment and Rishi Sunak’s response to Labour’s position on means-testing the payments. This source provides political context on the debate between Labour and the Conservatives​(POLITICO).
• House of Commons Library: Offers detailed information on the proposed changes to the Winter Fuel Payment, highlighting concerns from both advocates and critics of the reform, including issues with means-testing and the impact on low-income pensioners​(House of Commons Library).
• LabourList: Covers the debate within the Labour Party and the reactions of different MPs, including Rachel Reeves defending the policy and criticisms from left-wing MPs and unions​(LabourList).
• The Independent: Provides insights into the refusal of the government to publish an impact assessment on the potential effects of the cuts before the parliamentary vote. It also highlights concerns from Labour figures about the implications for fuel poverty​(The Independent).

---

Two-tier Policing: The evidence is clear

The term “two-tier policing” has increasingly been used to describe the perception that law enforcement in the UK applies different standards to different groups, a concern that has gained traction with the rise of protests and political unrest in recent years. This perception has been particularly prominent under the new UK government, where critics allege that conservative-leaning demonstrators, particularly those aligned with right-wing causes, face harsher police responses compared to left-wing or environmental activists such as those from the Just Stop Oil movement. Conservative commentators argue that this disparity reflects an ideological bias in law enforcement, eroding trust in the system’s fairness.

One of the key moments fueling this debate was the handling of far-right riots and anti-migrant protests in 2024. Conservative figures like Nigel Farage accused police of leniency toward left-wing protesters while aggressively clamping down on right-wing demonstrations. Farage highlighted the contrasting responses to protests by far-right groups versus the more passive handling of left-leaning activists, claiming this to be clear evidence of “two-tier policing”​(The Spectator).

Journalists from The Spectator echoed these concerns, describing how law enforcement seems to be more focused on maintaining political correctness and avoiding criticism from progressive circles, rather than ensuring uniform application of the law. This inconsistency, they argue, creates a perception that protest groups aligned with certain political ideologies receive preferential treatment​(The Spectator).

Specific examples of perceived two-tier policing in the UK have fueled debates over the fair application of the law. One prominent example involves the contrasting treatment of climate activists from groups like Just Stop Oil and Extinction Rebellion compared to right-wing or conservative demonstrators.

Just Stop Oil Protests (2023-2024): Environmental activists from Just Stop Oil have frequently blocked roads and disrupted public events in protests aimed at halting fossil fuel projects. In several cases, despite causing widespread disruption, these protesters have received more lenient responses from the police. Media outlets and politicians have pointed out how these demonstrators often face lighter charges, such as fines or brief detentions, while supposed “right-wing” demonstrators have faced harsher penalties. For instance, in 2023, police were seen as negotiating with Just Stop Oil activists rather than using force, allowing them to continue protests for hours before action was taken​(The Spectator)​(The Critic Magazine).

Pro-Life Demonstrators Outside Abortion Clinics: Under the Public Order Act, new legislation has introduced “buffer zones” around abortion clinics, criminalizing protests or demonstrations within these zones. This has been criticized as a direct attempt to stifle pro-life activists, who argue they are being targeted unfairly compared to other protest groups. The pro-life movement contends that this is a clear example of two-tier policing, where their protests face more stringent restrictions than left-wing protests, which are often allowed more leeway even when causing disruption​(The Critic Magazine).

Catholic pro-life activist, Isabel Vaughan-Spruce gained attention for being arrested twice for silently i.e. “in her head” – praying outside abortion clinics in the UK. She was arrested under the Public Order Act, which enforces buffer zones around abortion clinics to prevent protests. Vaughan-Spruce was specifically arrested for silently praying near a clinic, an act that led to significant media attention and controversy over freedom of expression and the limits of protest in these zones. She has been exonerated twice and paid compensation from the Police.

Her case has become a focal point in the debate about whether such restrictions represent an infringement on civil liberties, particularly the right to free speech and religious expression. Vaughan-Spruce has argued that her actions were peaceful and not aimed at harassing anyone, while critics of the buffer zones suggest that such laws are being applied disproportionately to pro-life activists, showcasing an example of two-tier policing​(The Spectator)​(The Critic Magazine).

Anti-Immigration Protests: Anti-immigration protests, often accused non-credibly of being led by “far-right” groups, have typically been met with a heavy police presence and swift intervention. For example, in 2024, protests against the UK government’s immigration policies were quickly dispersed, with several arrests made, sometimes before any significant disruption occurred. Protesters were often treated as potential threats to public order, and law enforcement responded with preemptive measures like banning marches, issuing dispersal orders, and arresting individuals involved​(The Spectator).

These protests have consistently been categorized as high-risk events due to their potential for inciting violence or clashes with counter-protesters. Critics of this approach argue that it reflects a “zero-tolerance” attitude toward right-wing demonstrations, where the primary focus is on maintaining public order. This has fueled claims of two-tier policing, where anti-immigration protesters are treated more harshly than other political groups.

In contrast, pro-Palestinian marches in London have often received a different response from law enforcement. These large demonstrations, particularly in 2023 and 2024, saw tens of thousands of people taking to the streets to protest Israel’s actions in Gaza. Despite their size and occasional clashes with pro-Israel demonstrators, the police were generally seen to take a more hands-off approach, allowing the marches to proceed with minimal intervention. In many cases, the police focused on facilitating the right to protest rather than preemptively breaking up the marches. Even in instances where controversial slogans were chanted or symbols were displayed, law enforcement tended to prioritize de-escalation over immediate arrests​(The Spectator)​(The Critic Magazine).

In terms of arrests, pro-Palestinian demonstrations have led to nearly 200 arrests across London as of September 2024. Among these, 98 arrests were for suspected antisemitic offenses, while others were related to criminal damage, public order offenses, and racial or religiously aggravated offenses. Police have also arrested individuals for supporting proscribed terrorist organizations. Additionally, several counter-protesters were arrested for breaching the peace and assaulting police officers​(The Jerusalem Post)​(The Times of Israel).

This more lenient approach has sparked criticism, particularly from conservative commentators, who argue that pro-Palestinian protesters have been given more freedom to express views that, in some cases, border on extremism. These commentators argue that had similar rhetoric or actions been displayed in right-wing protests, the police response would likely have been far more severe.

In contrast to the relatively smaller number of arrests during events such as Tommy Robinson’s rally (where just two arrests were made), the large-scale pro-Palestinian demonstrations have required a more extensive police operation, reflecting the complexity and scale of managing such politically charged events​(CityAM)​(ITVX).

When comparing the police responses and statistics for the 2024 Notting Hill Carnival with the pro-Britain rally led by Tommy Robinson in July 2024, the differences in scale, policing tactics, and outcomes are evident.

The Notting Hill Carnival saw significant police involvement due to multiple incidents of violence and disorder. Over the two days of the event, there were 349 arrests for offenses such as possession of offensive weapons, assaults on police officers, sexual offenses, and drug-related crimes. Additionally, over 50 police officers were injured, and there were eight stabbings, two of which led to fatalities​(Policing Insight)​(Mynewsdesk)​(Police Professional). Despite the celebratory nature of the carnival, the high levels of crime, including assaults and knife-related violence, have sparked calls for a reevaluation of the policing approach to ensure better public safety in future years.

In contrast, the pro-Britain rally organized by Tommy Robinson in July 2024 saw a much smaller scale of incidents. Although the event attracted thousands of participants and counter-protesters, the police presence (around 1,000 officers) ensured minimal disruption. Only two arrests were made, both related to an assault on a participant of the counter-protest by Stand Up To Racism​(CityAM)​(Evening Standard). The police employed Public Order Act powers to keep opposing groups apart, and the overall tone of the event was heavily managed to prevent serious outbreaks of violence. This reflects a different strategy compared to the carnival, where crowd control and prevention of violence were much more challenging.

These examples underscore the ongoing criticism that law enforcement selectively applies pressure depending on the political ideology of the protesters. This perception has led to a growing concern that the UK is witnessing an erosion of equality before the law, particularly when it comes to issues tied to free speech and public order.

In addition to the policing disparities, concerns about the new government’s approach to freedom of expression have emerged, especially in light of legislation that critics say is designed to stifle dissent. The introduction of measures such as “buffer zones” around abortion clinics, which prevent protests or even expressions of support near clinic entrances, has been framed by conservative voices as a direct attack on free speech. Critics argue that these measures, while aimed at preventing harassment, disproportionately target pro-life demonstrators while allowing other groups more freedom to protest without interference​(The Critic Magazine).

The broader critique is that the government’s new policies, particularly under the Public Order Act, are establishing a precedent for selective policing and restrictions on certain forms of protest. Some commentators have pointed out that while laws are being applied more harshly to specific causes, groups seen as more in line with progressive agendas are granted leniency, thereby creating a dangerous “chilling effect” on free expression​(The Spectator)​(The Critic Magazine).

The concerns surrounding two-tier policing and the attack on free speech raise significant questions about the UK government’s commitment to equality before the law and the fundamental right to protest. As the debate continues, conservative voices are calling for greater scrutiny and reforms to ensure that policing remains impartial, and that freedom of expression is upheld for all citizens, regardless of their political stance.

---

Paths to God: Pope Francis’s Inclusive Challenge to Traditional Catholic Doctrine

Pope Francis’s statement regarding the validity of different religions came during an interreligious dialogue, where he remarked:

“Every religion is a way to arrive at God. There are different languages to arrive at God but God is God for all. If you start to fight saying ‘my religion is more important than yours,’ is that true? There is only one God, and we, our religions, are languages, paths to arrive at God. Someone Sikh, someone Muslim, someone Hindu, someone Christian, but these are different paths.”​(OnePeterFive)​(America Magazine).

In this quote, Francis underscores the importance of mutual respect between religions and the shared journey toward God, using the metaphor of different languages and paths to describe the diversity of faith traditions. While this statement has been celebrated by some for promoting interfaith dialogue, it has also faced criticism from more traditional Catholics who view it as conflicting with the Church’s historical teaching on the uniqueness of Christ as the sole means of salvation.

Criticism from Traditional Catholic Sources
One prominent critique comes from OnePeterFive, a conservative Catholic website, which argued that Pope Francis’s statements risk promoting a form of religious relativism. They highlighted concerns that the Pope’s remarks might be interpreted as suggesting all religions are equally valid, which undermines the Church’s long-held belief that salvation is achieved through Christ. The website referenced Pope Francis’s comparison of religions to different languages that all lead to God, calling it “problematic” for distorting traditional Catholic understanding​(OnePeterFive).

Other conservative voices, such as those from LifeSiteNews and Catholic Family News, have echoed similar criticisms, stating that this inclusive language could lead Catholics to mistakenly believe that evangelization and conversion to Christianity are no longer necessary. They fear this approach erodes the urgency of the Gospel’s message of salvation through Jesus Christ.

What the Magisterium says…

In his encyclical Quanta Cura, Pope Pius IX condemned the notion that all religions are equally valid paths to salvation. He rejected religious relativism and pluralism, stating:”They do not fear to foster that erroneous opinion, especially fatal to the Catholic Church and to the salvation of souls, called by Our Predecessor, Gregory XVI, insanity, namely, that ‘liberty of conscience and worship is each man’s personal right, which ought to be legally proclaimed and asserted in every rightly constituted society.'” (Quanta Cura, 3)This document reflects the pre-Vatican II position that only the Catholic Church holds the fullness of the truth necessary for salvation, and the idea of equality between religions was rejected.

Pope Leo XIII, in Satis Cognitum, addressed the Church’s understanding of salvation, emphasizing that unity with the Catholic Church is essential:”The Church is one because Jesus Christ is one, and cannot be divided… whoever is separated from the Church is separated from Christ.” (Satis Cognitum, 4)This encyclical underscores the belief that while non-Catholics may possess elements of truth, they are separated from the fullness of salvation, which resides in the Catholic Church alone.

In Mystici Corporis Christi, Pope Pius XII articulated the teaching that the Catholic Church is the Mystical Body of Christ, and salvation can only be found through it:”Only those are to be included as members of the Church who have been baptized and profess the true faith… For not every sin, however grave, causes a man to be excluded from the Body of the Church… but only those which separate one from the Body of Christ, as schism, heresy, or apostasy.” (Mystici Corporis Christi, 22)This encyclical solidifies the traditional Catholic belief that membership in the Church is essential for salvation.

The contemporary Church’s official position on this matter is laid out in several key documents, most notably Dominus Iesus (2000), issued by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith under then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (later Pope Benedict XVI). This document explicitly affirms that while elements of truth may exist in other religions, these paths do not offer salvation independent of Christ:

“The Church’s belief is that Jesus Christ is the only savior of all humanity, and that there is no other name under heaven by which we must be saved (cf. Acts 4:12). There is only one mediator between God and man, the man Jesus Christ” (Dominus Iesus, 14).

It further stresses that religions which do not recognize the divinity of Christ, including Islam and Judaism, cannot be seen as valid or equal paths to God:

“It would be contrary to the faith to consider the Church as one way of salvation alongside those constituted by other religions” (Dominus Iesus, 21).

Similarly, the Catechism of the Catholic Church emphasizes the necessity of the Church for salvation:

“The Church is necessary for salvation. Christ, present to us in his body, which is the Church, is the one mediator and the way of salvation” (CCC 846).

These magisterial teachings affirm that while respect and dialogue with other religions are important, they must not obscure the Church’s central belief in the unique salvific role of Christ.

Post-Vatican II Shifts and Criticism

Pope Francis’s emphasis on religious dialogue and the notion that different religions are “paths” to God represent a significant departure from these earlier teachings. While Vatican II’s Nostra Aetate recognized that other religions could contain elements of truth, it maintained that the fullness of salvation is found in Christ and His Church.

Traditional Catholic critics argue that Pope Francis’s inclusive statements risk weakening this central doctrine. Some, like those from OnePeterFive, assert that while interreligious respect is important, it must not come at the expense of proclaiming the uniqueness of Christ as the only way to God​(OnePeterFive). They point to these pre-Vatican II documents as evidence that the Church cannot equate other religions with the fullness of Catholic teaching.

In summary, pre-Vatican II magisterial teachings clearly affirmed the exclusivity of salvation through the Catholic Church, in contrast to Pope Francis’s more inclusive statements on other religions as paths to God. This tension between tradition and contemporary views continues to provoke debate within the Church.

---

The controversy surrounding Bishop John Fenwick and Rev. Brett Murphy within the Free Church of England (FCE) has escalated into a significant internal conflict, highlighting deeper tensions over leadership, transparency, and doctrinal integrity.

Murphy vs Fenwick: a church in crisis

The Free Church of England (FCE) is a small, independent Anglican denomination that was established in the mid-19th century. It emerged in 1844 as a response to increasing concerns about the influence of Anglo-Catholicism within the Church of England, particularly as the Oxford Movement began to promote more Catholic-oriented doctrines and liturgical practices. The FCE sought to preserve a more Protestant and Reformed Anglican identity, maintaining the simplicity of worship and rejecting what it saw as the “innovations” of ritualism and sacerdotalism (the belief in the priestly mediation of grace).

Rev. Brett Murphy, a former Church of England vicar, joined the Free Church of England after leaving the Anglican Church due to disagreements over what he viewed as doctrinal compromises, including the Church’s position on gender issues. Murphy publicly criticized the appointment of a transgender archdeacon and denounced what he called the Church of England’s “apostasy” and “heresy”​(Church Times). His conservative stance resonated with certain elements within the FCE, particularly those disillusioned with the Church of England’s perceived liberal direction.

However, in 2024, Murphy was unexpectedly dismissed from his post at Emmanuel Church, Morecambe, by Bishop John Fenwick. His license to minister was revoked, and the bishop removed his name from the FCE website before the appeals process had concluded. This dismissal sparked outrage among Murphy’s congregation, who accused Fenwick of acting prematurely and undermining the due process of the appeal. The parish council issued a public statement defending Murphy and expressing concern over the bishop’s handling of the case, claiming it violated confidentiality and fairness​(Anglican Ink © 2024)​(Anglican Mainstream).

Broader Leadership Struggles
This incident is part of a larger leadership crisis within the FCE. Bishop Fenwick has been facing increasing scrutiny from within the church, particularly from clergy in the Southern Diocese, where a number of key figures have called for his resignation. These critics allege that Fenwick’s leadership has caused significant division and disunity, citing concerns over transparency, governance, and doctrinal issues. One letter, signed by several clergy and lay members, accused Fenwick of ignoring accountability processes and making decisions that have led to churches leaving the denomination​(Anglican Ink © 2024)​(Anglican Ink © 2024).

Among the more serious allegations against Fenwick are claims that he published documents attempting to reinterpret the FCE’s founding principles and omitted parts of creeds in official church publications. His critics argue that this undermines the FCE’s doctrinal integrity and is a departure from its historical role as a Reformed and Protestant church​(Anglican Ink © 2024). The FCE’s South American Synod, representing churches in Brazil and Venezuela, has already voted to sever ties with Fenwick over these concerns​(Anglican Ink © 2024).

Doctrinal and Theological Tensions
The controversy also underscores deeper theological tensions within the FCE, particularly as the denomination attracts conservative clergy who have left the Church of England. Figures like Rev. Brett Murphy, Calvin Robinson, and Matthew Firth have found a temporary home in the FCE, bringing with them a strong emphasis on traditional Anglican teachings and a resistance to what they perceive as the liberal drift in the wider Anglican Communion. However, their strong personalities and influence have led to clashes with established leadership within the FCE, particularly with Bishop Fenwick​(Anglican Ink © 2024).

Murphy’s dismissal, and the broader dissatisfaction with Fenwick’s leadership, point to a struggle over the future direction of the FCE. Will it remain a small, conservative offshoot of the Church of England, or will it embrace the growing number of conservative Anglicans looking for a spiritual home? This question remains open as the church grapples with its identity and governance amid this internal crisis.

Conclusion
The crisis involving Bishop John Fenwick and Rev. Brett Murphy reveals deep-rooted challenges within the Free Church of England. The clash between conservative theological forces and established leadership highlights the difficulty of maintaining unity in a small denomination facing external pressure and internal discord. The outcome of this conflict will likely shape the future of the FCE and its role within the broader Anglican tradition.

---

Combatting the Harmful Effects of Pornography Through Traditional Catholic Education

In today’s digital world, pornography has become an overwhelming societal issue, deeply affecting young adults both emotionally and spiritually. Recent studies highlight a significant correlation between frequent pornography use and heightened feelings of depression, loneliness, and hopelessness. According to research conducted by the Institute for Family Studies/YouGov, 32% of daily pornography viewers report constant feelings of depression, compared to only 19% of non-viewers. Additionally, 36% of regular viewers report feeling lonely, compared to 20% of those who abstain.

From a Catholic perspective, this issue transcends psychological damage, reaching deep into spiritual well-being. Pornography distorts the sacredness of human sexuality, turning a gift designed for love and unity into a source of objectification and exploitation. These are not just psychological consequences but also spiritual wounds that traditional Catholic teaching can help address. To combat this, Catholic families, particularly those dedicated to home education, must return to the core principles found in Church teachings, especially those promulgated before the Second Vatican Council, when the Church was vocal about purity, chastity, and moral integrity.

Pornography’s Addictive Nature and Its Psychological Impact
Pornography’s addictive potential is well-documented in modern psychology. Studies reveal that it affects the brain similarly to addictive substances like drugs or alcohol. Repeated consumption alters the brain’s reward system, causing desensitization and an increased need for more extreme content to achieve the same arousal level. This phenomenon, referred to as “tolerance,” is common in substance addiction and applies equally to pornography. Eventually, this leads to compulsive behavior and feelings of despair, shame, and guilt—emotions that further fuel the cycle of addiction.

Psychologically, pornography viewers often experience deep emotional isolation. This stems from the erosion of true intimacy, which is replaced by artificial and fleeting satisfaction. Over time, individuals can become incapable of forming meaningful, loving relationships, as they subconsciously seek to replicate the distorted images and scenarios seen in pornography. This not only damages romantic relationships but also harms self-esteem and interpersonal connections, leading to an overall sense of emptiness.

The Call to Purity
To understand the moral gravity of pornography, we must look to traditional Catholic teaching, which has long emphasized the importance of purity and chastity. One of the key magisterial documents that addresses this is Pope Pius XI’s encyclical, Casti Connubii (1930). In this document, the Pope condemns the misuse of sexuality outside of its proper context, calling any distortion of the marital act a grave sin. Pornography, which severs sexuality from love, marriage, and procreation, falls under this category of grave offenses. Pius XI warns against practices that debase human dignity and make sexuality a tool for pleasure rather than an expression of love within marriage.

Another critical document is Pope Pius XII’s encyclical Sacra Virginitas (1954), which emphasizes the virtue of chastity, especially for those pursuing a life of holiness. While this encyclical is primarily focused on virginity as a form of life, it speaks to all Catholics about the importance of purity in their thoughts and actions. The document reminds us that chastity is not merely a call for those consecrated to religious life but for every baptized Christian. Purity is essential for drawing closer to God and living in accordance with His will.

These magisterial teachings, deeply rooted in Sacred Tradition, provide a framework for understanding why pornography is not merely a personal failing but an affront to human dignity. It is not simply the act of viewing sexually explicit material that is sinful; it is the distortion of God’s gift of sexuality and the consequent objectification of people made in His image.

The Saints as Models of Purity and Overcoming Temptation
Catholic tradition is rich with the examples of saints who provide guidance for those struggling with temptations, including the temptations of the flesh. St. Maria Goretti, a martyr for purity, is one of the most powerful examples. Maria was a young girl who resisted sexual advances, choosing to defend her purity even unto death. Her story illustrates the importance of remaining steadfast in virtue, even in the face of overwhelming temptation.

Similarly, St. Augustine of Hippo, before his conversion, lived a life of hedonism and immorality. His Confessions detail his struggles with lust and his eventual realization that only God’s grace could fill the void left by a life of sin. Augustine’s profound transformation shows that, no matter how deep someone is in sin, there is always hope for redemption through God’s grace.

Another inspiring figure is St. Thomas Aquinas, who, when confronted with the temptation of sexual sin, turned to prayer and invoked divine assistance to remain chaste. Through the intercession of angels, Aquinas was preserved in purity and later became one of the greatest theologians in Church history. His life demonstrates the power of prayer and divine grace in overcoming temptations of the flesh.

The Role of Catholic Home Education: Forming Virtuous Minds
Given the moral and psychological dangers of pornography, Catholic families must be proactive in educating their children about the sacredness of human sexuality and the importance of living a chaste life. Home education, rooted in Catholic teaching, offers an ideal environment to instill these virtues from an early age. Unlike public or even some private schools, Catholic home education allows parents to control the content their children are exposed to, ensuring that their education aligns with the values of the faith.

In Pope Pius XI’s encyclical Divini Illius Magistri (1929), he affirms the primary role of parents as the first educators of their children. Parents are tasked with not only imparting academic knowledge but also forming their children in virtue and morality. Catholic home education enables parents to fulfill this role by incorporating teachings on human dignity, the purpose of sexuality, and the call to live a life of purity and chastity.

Moreover, the Catechism of the Council of Trent (1566) emphasizes the need for Christians to practice modesty and chastity in all aspects of life, a teaching that should be central to any Catholic curriculum. Parents can use this framework to teach their children about the dangers of pornography and why it is a violation of God’s commandments, particularly those concerning purity and love.

Combating Addiction Through Catholic Spiritual Practices
For those already caught in the snare of pornography addiction, Catholic spiritual practices offer a path to healing. The regular reception of the Sacrament of Confession is one of the most powerful tools in overcoming addiction. Confession provides not only forgiveness but also the grace necessary to resist future temptations. Frequent confession encourages accountability, helping individuals to reflect on their actions and commit to living a holier life.

Additionally, prayer and fasting are essential in the battle against pornography. By fasting, individuals strengthen their self-discipline, learning to deny their immediate desires in pursuit of a higher good. This practice can be applied to overcoming pornography by teaching the individual to control their impulses and focus on spiritual nourishment instead.

The Rosary, a powerful tool for invoking the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary, is particularly effective in combating temptations against purity. Mary, the model of perfect chastity, offers protection and guidance for those striving to live a pure life. Praying the Rosary daily, particularly with the intention of overcoming sexual sin, allows individuals to draw closer to Christ through His Blessed Mother and receive the grace to resist temptation.

Restoring Dignity and Healing Relationships
Beyond individual healing, it is essential to recognize the damage pornography does to relationships, particularly within marriage. Pornography fosters unrealistic expectations and undermines genuine intimacy between spouses. It reduces the marital act, which is meant to be a self-giving and loving union, to mere gratification.

Pope Pius XI’s teachings in Casti Connubii remind us that marriage is a sacred institution ordained by God, meant for the procreation of children and the mutual support of the spouses. Pornography, by promoting selfish pleasure, violates this sacred bond and can lead to marital discord. Catholic teaching encourages married couples to seek healing through the Sacrament of Matrimony, which provides the grace needed to restore trust, communication, and love in a relationship marred by pornography.

Catholic counseling, grounded in the Church’s teachings on human dignity and sexuality, can also be a valuable resource for couples seeking to rebuild their relationship after the damage caused by pornography. By focusing on the virtues of chastity, fidelity, and self-giving love, couples can work towards a deeper understanding of each other and a stronger union in Christ.

Conclusion: The Urgency of Catholic Action
The proliferation of pornography in modern society presents a grave threat to both psychological health and spiritual well-being. Traditional Catholic teaching, reinforced by the wisdom of the saints and the magisterium, provides the necessary tools for resisting this evil and promoting a culture of chastity and purity.

Catholic home education stands as a beacon of hope in a world inundated with sexual immorality. By instilling strong moral foundations and fostering a deep relationship with God, Catholic parents can protect their children from the pervasive influence of pornography and help them develop the virtues necessary for a life of holiness.

In the words of Pope Pius XII, “The purity of the soul is the glory of our lives and the shield of our families.” As Catholic families take up the call to protect their children from the dangers of pornography, they contribute not only to the salvation of individual souls but to the restoration of the moral fabric of society itself. Through prayer, the sacraments, and a firm commitment to Catholic teaching, families can overcome the challenges of modernity and raise a generation that honors God in mind, body, and soul.

---

World Vision Urges UK to Prioritize Global Child Welfare in Foreign Policy

World Vision UK has delivered a petition to Downing Street, urging the British government to place children’s welfare at the core of its foreign policy and aid initiatives. Signed by over 1,500 advocates, the petition highlights the urgent needs of children around the world, especially those facing extreme poverty and violence in conflict zones such as Ukraine, Gaza, and Sudan. Globally, 333 million children live in extreme poverty, while over 400 million grow up in war zones, exposing them to risks like abuse and human trafficking. The petition emphasizes that children are not mere statistics but individuals with futures that need protection.

The petition also calls for the UK government to honor its 1991 ratification of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) by integrating children’s rights into foreign policy and appointing a Special Envoy for Children within the Foreign, Commonwealth, and Development Office (FCDO). This move would ensure that children’s voices are heard in policymaking. Moreover, the petition stresses the economic and moral importance of prioritizing children in aid. World Vision UK cites data showing that every £1 spent on child-related activities generates £10 in return, underlining that investing in children is both a moral and economically sound choice​(World Vision)​(Christian Today).

World Vision, the organization behind this petition, is a global humanitarian organization founded in 1950. It operates in nearly 100 countries, focusing on poverty alleviation, disaster relief, and child protection. Driven by Christian values, World Vision’s mission is to ensure that vulnerable children are protected and their futures secured. One of its most recognized programs is child sponsorship, where individual donors support children and their communities. World Vision’s efforts extend beyond immediate relief to long-term development, aiming to build resilience within communities affected by conflict, poverty, and natural disasters​(World Vision)​(Christian Today)​(World Vision).

This petition is part of World Vision’s broader advocacy work to push governments to act on behalf of children. Alongside investment in children, the organization also stresses the importance of consulting with children and youth directly in decision-making processes, as young people are uniquely positioned to articulate their own needs and propose solutions to the crises they face​(World Vision).

---

---

Thousands Rally in London for March for Life UK: Advocates Declare ‘Abortion Isn’t Healthcare’

The 2024 March for Life UK in London drew thousands of participants to advocate for the protection of unborn life, with the theme “Abortion isn’t Healthcare” at the heart of the event. This annual march has grown into a significant occasion for the UK’s pro-life community, drawing attention to abortion issues and promoting alternatives.

The day began with multi-denominational church services involving Catholics, Protestants, and Orthodox Christians, reflecting the broad Christian support for the event. The gathering aimed to unite voices across theological divides on the sanctity of life, with a clear message that life should be protected from conception. As participants processed from the Emmanuel Centre in Westminster to Parliament Square, the event symbolized a public stand against the current UK laws and practices on abortion.

One of the key speakers, Dr. Haywood Robinson, a former abortionist, passionately addressed the crowd. Drawing on his experience as a physician, he rejected the idea that abortion is part of legitimate healthcare, saying that healthcare is meant to heal, not harm. His transformation from an abortion provider to a leading pro-life advocate has made him a powerful voice in these movements, and his speeches often emphasize the deep ethical and moral implications of abortion​(Christian Concern)​(Christian Post).

Ethicist Dr. Calum Miller and fertility specialist Ira Winter also spoke, adding academic and medical perspectives to the discussions on life and healthcare. Miller, known for his work on medical ethics and abortion, highlighted the inconsistencies in the argument that abortion is a healthcare necessity. Fertility specialist Winter underscored how modern medicine offers numerous alternatives to abortion, particularly in cases of unintended or complex pregnancies​(Right To Life UK).

Another notable voice was Dawn McEvoy of Both Lives Matter, a movement that works to reshape the conversation around abortion by highlighting that both the mother and unborn child deserve protection and care. McEvoy argued that pro-life advocacy is about supporting women with real, compassionate alternatives rather than pushing a divisive agenda​(Christian Post)​(Christian Today).

A key figure from the Catholic Church, Bishop John Sherrington, added his support to the movement by framing it as a moral and religious imperative to defend life. His presence underscored the Catholic Church’s firm stance on the issue, aligning it with broader efforts to influence legislation on life issues. Bishop Sherrington’s call for laws that reflect respect for life echoed the sentiments of many attendees who believe current UK abortion laws do not do enough to protect the unborn​(Christian Today).

Pastor Patrick Regan King, of The Angel Church in London, addressed a different but crucial issue within the evangelical community. He highlighted that, while many evangelical Christians may personally hold pro-life views, the issue is often avoided in sermons and church discussions due to its controversial nature. King advocated for more open dialogue on abortion in evangelical churches, framing it within the context of redemption and grace​(Christian Post).

The march also coincided with increasing public concern over rising abortion rates in the UK, especially since the introduction of telemedicine abortion services during the COVID-19 pandemic, which has allowed women to access abortion pills via mail. This shift in policy has intensified debates around abortion laws and sparked concern among pro-life groups about the ease of access to abortion and the potential health risks for women​(Right To Life UK)​(Christian Concern).

The March for Life UK is not just a protest but also a rallying cry for legislative change. The participants hope to influence policy by advocating for tighter restrictions on abortion and promoting support systems for women facing crisis pregnancies. As UK Parliament continues to review various amendments and proposals regarding abortion law, the pro-life movement aims to ensure that the voices of those advocating for life are heard clearly.

---

Jordan Peterson: the influence of “woke” in churches

Jordan Peterson, the Canadian psychologist and cultural commentator, has voiced strong criticism of what he perceives as the infiltration of “woke” ideology into Protestant churches, particularly through the display of rainbow flags, which he associates with “hedonistic pride.” In a recent interview at the premiere of Am I Racist?, a film featuring his colleague Matt Walsh, Peterson highlighted the increasing prevalence of identity politics within Christian institutions in Canada and the UK. He warned that this shift is causing churches to stray from foundational Christian teachings, threatening the integrity of the faith, especially among younger generations who are more susceptible to cultural trends.

Peterson also criticized the tendency for some religious communities, including conservative Evangelical churches, to be overtaken by self-serving figures, comparing them to the Pharisees in the Gospel, who used religion for personal gain. He urged Christians to be discerning, using biblical principles such as “by their fruits, you will know them” to identify true leaders from those who misuse faith for self-aggrandizement.

Despite his critiques, Peterson expressed hope in the revival of church attendance, particularly among conservative circles, seeing it as a potential avenue for instilling traditional religious values in children. He emphasized the importance of exposing children to biblical ideas, arguing that they provide an ethical framework to help navigate modern challenges such as the negative impact of social media and technology on social development.

Peterson, while not a professing Christian himself, frequently discusses Christian themes and stresses the cultural and moral importance of Christianity in shaping Western civilization. He has suggested that the Bible serves as the foundation for Western moral and ethical values​(Christian Post)​(End Time Headlines)​(Christian Post).

Jordan Peterson’s critique of the infiltration of “woke” ideology in Protestant churches mirrors concerns raised by many Catholic commentators about the secularization of both society and the Catholic Church. These voices emphasize how secularizing influences have increasingly shaped the beliefs and practices of Catholics, weakening their discipleship and witness in the modern world.

Secularization of the Church and its Impact on Discipleship
Catholic scholars and leaders have long warned against the dangers of secularism, which they see as prioritizing worldly values over spiritual truths. This process is seen not only in society at large but also within the Church itself. As Pope St. Pius X remarked in his 1907 encyclical Pascendi Dominici Gregis, modernist ideas—what we might now call secular ideologies—pose a profound threat to the Church by diminishing the authority of divine revelation in favor of human reason. He condemned efforts to adapt Christian teachings to contemporary societal trends, a concern that still resonates today.

Many Catholic commentators, such as Bishop Robert Barron, have pointed to a crisis of catechesis and discipleship within the Church, where many Catholics no longer understand or adhere to the core tenets of the faith. The rise of “culturally Catholic” individuals—those who identify as Catholic but do not actively practice or follow Church teachings—exemplifies this challenge. This phenomenon is sometimes referred to as Cafeteria Catholicism, where individuals pick and choose which parts of the faith to follow, often discarding teachings on moral issues like abortion, marriage, or sexuality. Cardinal Raymond Burke, a vocal critic of secular trends within the Church, has spoken against this selective adherence to Catholicism, warning that it weakens the Church’s ability to serve as a moral and spiritual guide.

“Culturally Catholic” and “Cafeteria Catholicism”
The idea of “culturally Catholic” refers to people who may participate in Catholic rituals—like baptisms, weddings, or funerals—without fully engaging with the faith’s spiritual demands. These Catholics may appreciate the cultural aspects of the religion, but their beliefs and practices are shaped more by secular values than by Church teachings. Pope Benedict XVI, in his writings and speeches, frequently warned about the dangers of this nominal Catholicism, which he viewed as contributing to the “dictatorship of relativism”—a worldview that denies objective truth in favor of individual preferences and societal trends​(Christian Post).

The term Cafeteria Catholicism encapsulates this idea of selective adherence to Church teachings. For instance, while some Catholics may embrace the Church’s social teachings on poverty and justice, they may reject its moral stances on issues like contraception or same-sex marriage. This piecemeal approach erodes the integrity of Catholic discipleship, according to figures like Cardinal Burke and Pope St. John Paul II, who repeatedly emphasized that Catholicism is an integrated whole, not a set of options to be selectively followed​(End Time Headlines)​(Christian Post).

Magisterial Warnings Against Secularizing Influences
Long before the current challenges, the pre-Vatican II magisterium consistently admonished the faithful to resist the creeping influence of secularism. In his 1864 encyclical Quanta Cura, Pope Pius IX condemned secular ideologies that sought to separate Church and state, as well as those that tried to undermine the authority of the Church in moral and social matters. He saw secularism as a direct threat to the spiritual health of the faithful.

Similarly, Pope Leo XIII’s 1885 encyclical Immortale Dei stressed the need for Catholics to defend their faith against the rising tide of secularization. He warned that by adopting secular principles, Christians risked diluting the core message of the Gospel. This concern was echoed in the 20th century by Pope Pius XII, who in his writings urged Catholics to remain vigilant in upholding the timeless truths of the Church in the face of modern cultural pressures​(End Time Headlines).

Revival of Traditional Discipleship
Despite these challenges, some Catholic leaders and commentators see signs of hope in a revival of traditional Catholicism. This resurgence, especially among younger generations, is often marked by a return to more orthodox teachings, the Latin Mass, and a deeper engagement with the sacraments. Bishop Barron has noted that this trend offers a potential path forward, as it encourages Catholics to embrace the fullness of their faith rather than conform to secular ideologies.

In conclusion, Peterson’s critique of the secularization of Protestant churches parallels ongoing concerns within the Catholic Church about the erosion of traditional values and the rise of Cafeteria Catholicism. Catholic leaders continue to urge the faithful to resist the temptations of secularism and embrace a holistic, faithful practice of their beliefs, grounded in the rich teachings of the Church and the timeless truths of the Gospel.

---

RECOMMENDED SUBSCRIPTION

From music to podcasts, video blogs and social media channels, the following is this week’s recommended subscription:

The Traditional Thomist YouTube channel, run by Nicholas Cavazos, offers content focused on Thomistic philosophy, traditional Catholic theology, and the Latin Mass. Cavazos, a passionate advocate of returning to the intellectual and spiritual traditions of the Church, frequently discusses topics such as Catholic Integralism, spiritual life, and contemporary issues through a Thomistic lens. His channel provides a mix of deep theological discussions, reflections on Catholic tradition, and critiques of modern secular influences within the Church.

Cavazos’s journey into Thomism and the Latin Mass is central to his channel’s narrative. He discusses his conversion to these traditional practices and emphasizes the importance of integrating Thomistic philosophy into daily Catholic living. His videos often explore how the teachings of St. Thomas Aquinas can be applied to current cultural and moral issues, advocating for a return to more traditional Catholic values.

One notable feature of his content is his collaboration with other traditional Catholic voices, including podcasts like “Glad Trad,” where he expands on topics like Catholic Integralism and the role of religion in shaping a just society. His engagement with audiences emphasizes practical spirituality, the challenges of living a deeply Catholic life in modern secular culture, and fostering a return to robust Catholic traditions, particularly in liturgy and catechesis.

For those interested in exploring classical Catholic thought and practice, the Traditional Thomist channel serves as a valuable resource, bridging Thomistic philosophy with contemporary Catholic issues and encouraging viewers to deepen their faith through tradition and intellectual engagement.

---

RECOMMENDED BOOKS

From theology to culture war there are some brilliant minds still publishing worthy, well-researched content heartily recommended to you for reading. These would make great additions to your own or another’s personal library, perhaps as a gift?

Phoenix from the Ashes: The Making, Unmaking, and Restoration of Catholic Tradition

Noble Beauty, Transcendent Holiness: Why the Modern Age Needs the Mass of Ages

The Popes Against Modern Errors: 16 Papal Documents

The Great Facade: The Regime of Novelty in the Catholic Church from Vatican II to the Francis Revolution (Second Edition)

---

RECOMMENDED VIEWING

Archbishop Viganò, Schism, and Francis—Marc Balestrieri

Apocalypse Now? Pope Sez ALL Religions the Way To God

Akita, Fatima, and Catholicism in Japan

What Should Catholics think of “Bishop of Rome” Document? Questions with Father #50

---

---

PRACTICUM

The following are ways in which you may practically support the work of others for the betterment of our society and the plight of sufferers, the impoverished and defenceless.

Prayer Requests

Pray for vocations
Pray for traditional seminaries and the creation of formation houses
The Church – contending with the crisis of faith

Pray for Bishop Nioclas Kelly about to undergo hip surgery
Pray for Eileen Butler diagnosed with colon cancer that has spread to her liver
Pray for Fr Stanislaus Ybarra FMCD diagnosed paraplegic from the waist down
Pray for Dr Janie Thomas recently deceased

Praying for vocations

In our times of spiritual and moral challenges, the need for vocations to the Traditional Catholic priesthood and religious life is more pressing than ever. Traditional Catholic communities, which adhere closely to the liturgical and doctrinal practices predating the Second Vatican Council, offer a profound and timeless witness to the faith. These communities emphasize the Tridentine Mass, the rich traditions of the Church, and a deep commitment to orthodoxy and reverence in worship.

Praying for vocations to these communities is essential for several reasons:

SPIRITUAL LEADERSHIP AND GUIDANCE: The spiritual formation offered in traditional seminaries and religious houses is rigorous and deeply rooted in the Church’s intellectual and spiritual traditions. Priests and religious formed in this environment are well-prepared to provide strong spiritual leadership and guidance to the faithful. They play a crucial role in fostering spiritual growth, administering the sacraments with reverence, and leading souls to Christ.

PRESERVATION OF LITURGICAL HERITAGE: Traditional Catholic communities are guardians of the Church’s ancient liturgical heritage. The Tridentine Mass, also known as the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite, offers a deeply contemplative and reverent worship experience that has nourished countless saints. By praying for vocations, we support the continuity of this sacred tradition and ensure that future generations can experience the beauty and depth of traditional Catholic worship.

WITNESS TO ORTHODOXY: In an age of doctrinal confusion and moral relativism, traditional Catholic communities stand as beacons of orthodoxy. Their unwavering commitment to the timeless teachings of the Church provides a clear and steadfast witness to the truth. Praying for vocations helps sustain this witness and equips the Church with priests and religious who can boldly proclaim the faith without compromise.

Response to a Growing Demand

There is a growing interest and demand for traditional liturgy and spirituality among the faithful. Many young people, in particular, are drawn to the beauty and depth of traditional Catholic practices. By praying for vocations, we support the growth of these communities and respond to the spiritual needs and desires of many who seek a deeper connection with their faith.

Please pray for the new formation house proposed by Archbishop Vigano, and likewise our own effort to establish a formation house under my own aegis here in Brighton.

In conclusion, praying for vocations to the priesthood and religious life is essential for the Church, especially during times of crisis. It is a way to invite Christ to send more laborers to the harvest, honor the contributions of religious orders, and ask for their intercession in renewing the Church. By praying for vocations during this time, we are participating in the Church’s mission to spread the Gospel and to build a stronger, more vibrant faith community.

---

Restore Justice for Rev. Dr. Bernard Randall: End the Church of England’s Unfair Blacklisting

Rev. Dr. Bernard Randall, a former Church of England chaplain, was dismissed after delivering a sermon upholding Christian teachings on marriage and advising against feeling pressured to accept any ideology. Despite being cleared by various authorities, he remains blacklisted by his diocese as a safeguarding risk, solely for his adherence to biblical teachings. Legal challenges have revealed serious errors in the Church’s handling of his case. Six months on, Bernard is still barred from ministry, forcing him to seek other work.

Read more and sign the petition to demand the Church of England stop this unjust punishment and restore his position.

---

New Threat to Legalize Assisted Suicide in the UK

Only a few weeks into the new Parliament, a new threat to legalize assisted suicide has emerged. Lord Falconer’s Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults Bill secured second place in the Lord’s ballot for private members’ bills. Concurrently, a similar bill is under debate on the Isle of Man and has been approved in principle in Jersey.

The most pressing concern is in Scotland, where Liam McArthur MSP introduced the Assisted Dying Scotland Bill on March 27, 2024. The Health, Social Care and Sport Committee at Holyrood is calling for evidence on this bill, and responses are crucial by August 16, 2024. This consultation will influence the Committee’s recommendation on whether the bill should proceed.

Ethical and Practical Concerns

Opponents of assisted suicide argue that legalizing such practices can lead to significant ethical and practical issues. According to Right to Life UK, concerns include the potential for abuse, pressure on vulnerable individuals, and the undermining of trust in medical professionals. There is also the argument that legalizing assisted suicide can create a slippery slope leading to the normalization of euthanasia.

The pro-assisted suicide lobby is expected to make persistent efforts to legalize assisted suicide in the coming months and years. It is vital for opponents to be prepared to respond to these attempts, starting with the current threat in Scotland.

Key Points:

• Terminology: “Assisted dying” is often used as a euphemism for assisted suicide and euthanasia. The UK proposals focus on assisted suicide, not euthanasia.
• Reasons for Assisted Suicide: Common reasons include fear of becoming a burden, loss of autonomy, and fear of future pain rather than current pain.
• Impact on Disabled People: Many disabled people and their advocacy groups oppose assisted suicide, fearing coercion and a reduction in their perceived value.
• Safeguards and Slippery Slope: Evidence from other countries shows that safeguards around assisted suicide often erode over time, leading to broader and potentially more dangerous practices.
• Effect on Suicide Rates: Legalizing assisted suicide has been associated with an increase in overall suicide rates.
• Palliative Care: Good palliative care can alleviate the primary reasons people seek assisted suicide. However, the availability and quality of palliative care can be undermined by the legalization of assisted suicide.
• Economic Pressures: There are concerns that financial pressures might lead to the promotion of assisted suicide as a cost-saving measure in healthcare systems.

Safeguarding risks

In Canada, since legalizing medically assisted death (MAiD) in 2016, the scope has expanded from terminally ill patients to include those with mental health conditions and marginalized individuals facing socio-economic pressures. Reports have shown cases where people seek assisted death due to poverty or inadequate housing rather than terminal illness.

Similarly, in the Netherlands and Belgium, initial restrictions on euthanasia have gradually loosened. For example, the number of dementia patients receiving euthanasia in the Netherlands has increased significantly, raising concerns about consent and the potential for abuse. Moreover, in Belgium, reports indicated a percentage of infant deaths involved active euthanasia by lethal injection, highlighting the risk of extending euthanasia practices to non-consenting or vulnerable populations.

These examples illustrate that once assisted suicide or euthanasia is legalized, the protections meant to safeguard vulnerable individuals often weaken, leading to broader applications that can endanger lives.

Increased Suicide Rates

Evidence from multiple studies indicates that legalizing assisted suicide is associated with an increase in overall suicide rates. Research analyzing the impact of assisted suicide laws in ten U.S. states showed a significant increase in total suicide rates following the legalization of assisted suicide. This increase was particularly notable among the elderly and women, with total suicide rates rising by about 18% overall and by 40% for women specifically​​​​.

Additionally, another study highlighted that legalizing assisted suicide might lower societal taboos against suicide, thereby potentially increasing the overall inclination towards suicide, not just assisted suicide​​. This is consistent with findings from European countries where the introduction of assisted suicide or euthanasia laws has not reduced non-assisted suicide rates but, in some cases, has led to an increase.

These findings suggest that rather than providing a safeguard, the legalization of assisted suicide may inadvertently contribute to higher rates of both assisted and unassisted suicides, challenging the notion that such laws offer a protective measure against suicide. This underscores the need for careful consideration of the broader societal impacts of legalizing assisted suicide.

How to Respond

Supporters in Scotland, and throughout the UK, are encouraged to respond to the consultation. It’s essential to use personal words rather than identical responses, as the Committee will disregard duplicates. Including professional expertise or personal stories can add weight to your response.

The pro-assisted suicide lobby is expected to make persistent efforts to legalize assisted suicide in the coming months and years. It is vital for opponents to be prepared to respond to these attempts, starting with the current threat in Scotland.

Please respond to this consultation by 16 August 2024.

There is a short survey and a more detailed call for evidence. SPUC (Society for the Protection of the Unborn Children) has produced a guide explaining both options and giving advice on how to respond to the questions.

Action Steps

1. Respond to the Consultation: The Committee’s decision will hinge on public feedback. Use the provided guide to craft a personalized response.
2. Who Should Respond: While responses from Scotland are crucial, input from across the UK is also important as the outcome in Scotland could influence decisions in Westminster.
3. What to Say: Draw from personal experience and professional expertise. Avoid identical responses to ensure your submission is considered.

The next few months are critical in the fight against the legalization of assisted suicide. Your participation can make a significant difference.

---

Help Rescue the Freedom of Speech Act

In July, the UK’s Secretary of State for Education, Bridget Phillipson, issued a statement to the House of Commons indicating her intention to halt the commencement of the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act “in order to consider options, including its repeal.”

It was fitting that the Labour Government would declare war on free speech in a written statement, posted quietly to the House of Commons website on a Friday – a good day for bad news, as any journalist will tell you – and unaccompanied by any opportunity for parliamentary debate or scrutiny.

The Freedom of Speech Act was a carefully crafted piece of legislation, properly debated in both Houses of Parliament, and designed to address the free speech crisis in universities. It aimed to strengthen the legal duty on English universities to uphold and promote freedom of speech and introduced enforcement mechanisms, such as a complaints scheme overseen by the higher education regulator, to ensure universities adhered to this duty.

Having received cross-party support during the last Parliament, its most important clauses were due to be commenced on 1st August.

However, because Rishi Sunak called an election before the Act had been fully implemented, this Government has seized its chance to derail it.

The FSU has sent a pre-action protocol letter to the Education Secretary, threatening a judicial review if she does not reverse her decision.

To increase the chances of rescuing this vital piece of legislation, it is also necessary to maintain pressure on MPs. The FSU has provided a campaigning tool (here) to write to your local MP, urging them to ask Ms Phillipson to think again.

Completing the form is a simple is a simple, fast process that can have a significant impact. A template is provided to assist, but personalisation is encouraged. Every voice matters, and it is vital that individuals make theirs heard.

The threat to judicially review Bridget Phillipson’s decision is the first legal action this Government is facing, and anything involving lawyers is expensive.

Donations to the Fighting Fund to help cover some of these costs are welcome. Contributions can be made through the provided link. The FSU appreciates all support in this matter.

---

The Debate on Trans-Inclusive Conversion Therapy Bans

A recent case in Switzerland has highlighted the complexities and potential consequences of legislative measures related to conversion therapy. A 15-year-old Swiss girl was taken into state care after her parents refused to consent to a course of puberty blockers following a disputed diagnosis of gender dysphoria. This incident underscores the contentious nature of proposed legislative changes in the UK, as outlined in Sir Keir Starmer’s recent King’s Speech.

Labour’s Legislative Agenda

During the King’s Speech, Sir Keir Starmer presented his legislative programme for the current Parliamentary session, emphasizing Labour’s commitment to enacting a “full, trans-inclusive ban on conversion practices.” The proposal, while intended to protect vulnerable individuals from harmful conversion therapies, has raised significant concerns regarding free speech and the practical implications of such a ban.

Definitional Ambiguities

The term “conversion practices” remains ambiguously defined, leading to uncertainties about what actions and advice might be prohibited under the new law. This lack of clarity poses a risk to the freedoms enshrined in Articles 9 and 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protect freedom of thought and expression, respectively. The potential for these rights to be compromised is a major point of contention among critics of the proposed ban.

Concerns from the Free Speech Union (FSU)

The Free Speech Union (FSU) has voiced fears that a hastily implemented, poorly defined ban could severely restrict the ability of parents, teachers, religious leaders, and health professionals to engage in open dialogue with gender-confused children. The concern is that advocating for a child to consider all options and reflect before undergoing irreversible medical procedures could be misconstrued as a form of conversion therapy, thus falling foul of the new legislation.

The Swiss Case as a Cautionary Tale

The situation in Switzerland serves as a stark warning. In some cantons, where conversion therapy is already banned, a couple lost custody of their 15-year-old daughter because they did not agree to her taking puberty blockers immediately following her gender dysphoria diagnosis. This incident illustrates the potential extreme outcomes of such bans, where parental rights and alternative medical opinions may be overridden by a rigid interpretation of “gender affirmative care.”

Defining “Conversion Therapy” and Its Implications

Defining “conversion therapy” in a broad and imprecise manner could inadvertently criminalize standard religious practices and pastoral care. For instance, traditional religious counseling that encourages individuals to embrace their birth gender or offers prayer and spiritual guidance could be misconstrued as conversion therapy. This could lead to legal repercussions for clergy and lay counselors practicing their faith. The ambiguity in the definition risks entangling religious expressions and pastoral care in legal disputes, infringing on religious freedoms and the rights of individuals to seek spiritual guidance.

Ministerial Consultation Response

Archbishop Jerome of the Old Roman Apostolate has expressed significant concerns over similar legislation proposed in the UK, highlighting that the lack of clarity in defining “conversion therapy” could inadvertently criminalize standard religious practices and pastoral care. He stresses the need for precise language to ensure that legitimate religious and moral guidance is not misinterpreted as coercive or harmful practices.

Legitimate Religious and Moral Guidance

Legitimate religious and moral guidance refers to the spiritual advice and support provided by religious leaders and communities based on their beliefs and teachings. This includes counseling individuals to adhere to their faith’s principles, praying for them, and offering moral direction. The concern is that without clear definitions, these standard practices could be wrongfully classified as conversion therapy, leading to legal challenges and restrictions on religious freedom.

The Need for a Balanced Approach

Critics argue that a balanced approach is essential. While protecting individuals from genuine harm is paramount, it is equally important to safeguard the right to free speech and to ensure that all treatment options can be openly discussed. The fear is that without clear, precise definitions and protections, well-meaning legislation could lead to unintended and severe consequences, such as those seen in the Swiss case.

PSHEbrighton: Local Support for Parents and Families

A Brighton family, with support from PSHEbrighton, is threatening legal action against Brighton & Hove City Council over its “Classroom to Clinic” guidance, which advises schools on supporting transgender pupils. The family argues that the guidance encourages schools to facilitate children’s gender changes without parental consent, infringing on parental rights and potentially leading to irreversible medical decisions without proper oversight. They are particularly concerned that the policy allows schools to keep parents in the dark about their child’s gender transition, bypassing necessary medical consultations and psychological evaluations.

PSHEbrighton, an organization co-founded by Archbishop Jerome to support parents and families in similar situations, backs the family’s stance. They emphasize the importance of parental involvement in such significant decisions and highlight the need for policies that protect both children’s well-being and parental rights. The family’s lawyer has warned that if the council does not retract the guidance, legal action will proceed on grounds of violating parental rights and failing to provide proper duty of care to the children. The council defends its policy as a means to support transgender students and promote inclusivity in schools, but the case underscores the ongoing tensions and legal complexities surrounding transgender rights and parental consent in educational settings.

Schools in England and Wales are facing potential lawsuits from parents over their use of a gender toolkit that advises on supporting transgender students. The legal opinion by Karon Monaghan KC, recognised as the UK’s leading Human Rights lawyer, suggests the toolkit produced by Brighton & Hove City Council but used widely by other local authorities, fails in safeguarding and Equality Act legislation. The toolkit, intended to foster inclusivity, includes guidelines on allowing students to change their names and pronouns and access facilities corresponding to their gender identity, often without parental consent. Critics argue that these guidelines bypass parental rights and medical oversight, potentially leading to irreversible decisions about children’s gender transitions.

Action for Concerned Citizens

Given these concerns, the FSU is encouraging its members and the general public to voice their apprehensions by contacting their MPs. The FSU has provided an automated campaigning tool to facilitate this process, emphasizing the need to protect free speech, especially in contexts that could have life-altering consequences.

Conclusion

As the debate around trans-inclusive conversion therapy bans continues, it is crucial to strike a careful balance that protects individuals from harm while preserving fundamental rights to free thought and expression. The case of the Swiss teen underscores the importance of getting this balance right, to ensure that legislative measures do not inadvertently cause more harm than good.

---

Sir Keir Starmer must be reminded that free speech is a fundamental human right

The Prime Minister’s recent crackdown on free speech is extremely concerning. Since early August, we have witnessed the most significant attack on free expression in this country since Oliver Cromwell outlawed all theatrical performances in 1642.

In response to the civil unrest that spread across the UK following the tragic killing of three children in Southport, Sir Keir has attributed the surge in violence to ‘misinformation’ and ‘disinformation’ on social media. He has called on authorities to prosecute individuals for making supposedly inflammatory statements online.

As a consequence, one man has been sentenced to 18 months in prison for sharing something “offensive” that someone else posted on Facebook, another was imprisoned for three years for posting “anti-Establishment rhetoric,” and a third was jailed for 18 months for chanting “Who the f*** is Allah?”

Stephen Parkinson, the Director of Public Prosecutions, has even issued a warning that people who share footage of the riots online could face prosecution. “People might think they’re not doing anything harmful, but they are, and the consequences will be visited upon them,” he said.

This kind of threatening language is more characteristic of a repressive regime than the birthplace of parliamentary democracy. It has sparked widespread fear across the country, with hundreds of thousands now worried they could be imprisoned for posting something politically incorrect online.

This must end. We need to remind the Prime Minister, a former human rights lawyer, that free speech is the cornerstone of all other rights; without it, we cannot defend any of the others.

Here’s how you can take action: If you’re concerned about the Prime Minister’s attack on free speech, please use our campaign tool to write to your local MP using our template letter.

Completing the form is simple and straightforward.

Here’s how you can take action

If you’re concerned about the Prime Minister’s assault on free speech, please use the FSU campaigning tool to write to your local MP, using the template letter.

Completing the form is a simple, fast process that can have a significant impact. We’ve even provided a template to help, but feel free to personalise it. Your voice matters and it’s vital that you make it heard.

---

Become a Warrior Teacher

The Winning Mindset is an organization that recognizes the necessity for a more balanced and discerning approach to engaging with the information-rich world we inhabit. Their educational seminars are specifically designed to inspire individuals to think deeply and critically, fostering personal growth and development. By refining these skills, individuals can enhance their ability to counter popular arguments and challenge the prevailing mindset.

The Winning Mindset is an organization that recognizes the necessity for a more balanced and discerning approach to engaging with the information-rich world we inhabit. Their educational seminars are specifically designed to inspire individuals to think deeply and critically, fostering personal growth and development. By refining these skills, individuals can enhance their ability to counter popular arguments and challenge the prevailing mindset.

---

Petitions

Current Public Petitions Regarding Relationships & Sex Education (RSE) in the UK

There are several public petitions related to Relationships and Sex Education (RSE) in the UK, reflecting various concerns and opinions on the subject. Here are some notable ones:

1. Strip Ruth Hunt of her peerage for her role in the gender medical scandal
   • Summary: There has been wide cross-party support for the Cass Review, which delivered stinging criticisms of NHS gender clinics and found that for most young people, a medical pathway is not the best way to treat gender-related distress. It also found there is little or no evidence about the long-term effects of puberty blockers and sex hormones for the under-18s.
   • Link: Change.Org
2. New RSHE guidance for schools MUST become law
   • Summary: Following the election, it will be the responsibility of the incoming government and the new Education Secretary to review this consultation and decide whether to uphold the guidance and whether it should be statutory – which means schools MUST follow it.
   • Link: CitizenGo
3. Stop divisive Progress Pride flag displays
   • Summary: Christian Concern is objecting to a massive display of Progress Pride flags planned for Regent Street in 2024. These divisive, gaudy displays are completely inappropriate for this historic, iconic street at the centre of London. They make everyone who doesn’t support the whole LGBTQ+ agenda feel unwelcome.
   • Link: CitizenGo
4. Labour’s ‘conversion therapy’ ban will harm children, criminalise parents, and place restrictions on talking and praying
   • Summary: Labour has confirmed it will proceed with its pledged “trans-inclusive” ban on ‘conversion therapy’ and ‘conversion practices’. Announcing that work has begun on a ban, Sir Keir Starmer said it was “a promise that has lingered in the lobby of good intentions for far too long”. While the specifics of the ban remain unclear, it is important to note that harmful physical ‘conversion practices’ do not happen in the UK and are already illegal. Therefore, any ban on ‘conversion practices’ would primarily impact free speech, including consensual conversations, counselling, and even prayer.
   • Link: CitizenGo

For more detailed information, you can refer to the specific petitions linked above and the GOV.UK website, which provides comprehensive guidance and updates on RSE policies.

Current Public Petitions Regarding Changes to the UK’s Abortion Laws

There are several active public petitions in the UK addressing proposed changes to abortion laws. These petitions reflect a wide range of perspectives on this highly contentious issue. Here are some of the notable petitions:

1. Remove references to ‘gender identity’ from relationships education guidance
   • Summary: This petition argues against the inclusion of gender identity in RSE guidance, citing concerns about political indoctrination and inconsistency with the Education Act.
   • Link: Remove references to ‘gender identity’
2. Review abortion laws to reduce the gestational limit
   • Summary: A cross-party group of MPs has proposed reducing the upper gestational limit for abortions from 24 weeks to 22 weeks. This petition supports the amendment, highlighting that medical advancements have increased the survival rate of babies born at 22 weeks.
   • Link: Right to Life UK
3. Ban sex-selective abortions
   • Summary: This petition seeks to make it explicitly illegal to perform abortions based on the sex of the fetus, addressing concerns that sex-selective abortions are occurring in the UK despite current legal ambiguities.
   • Link: Right to Life UK
4. Oppose decriminalisation of abortion
   • Summary: This petition opposes any move to decriminalise abortion in the UK, arguing that current laws provide necessary safeguards to ensure ethical medical practice and protect both women and unborn children.
   • Link: British Medical Association
5. End ‘DIY’ Abortion Services
   • Summary: This petition calls for the cessation of ‘DIY’ abortion services, arguing that they endanger women’s lives and lack proper medical supervision, thus advocating for stricter regulations.
   • Link: Right to Life UK
6. A General Election has been called for 4 July 2024
   • Summary: Please contact your MP now asking them to make it clear to their party leadership that abortion decriminalisation and assisted suicide should not be included in manifestoes. You can use our tool below.
   • Link: SPUC

Current Public Petitions Regarding Abortion Laws in the USA

1. Nebraska Right to Abortion Initiative (2024)
   • Summary: This initiative proposes an amendment to the Nebraska Constitution to establish a right to abortion until fetal viability, defined by the professional judgment of the treating healthcare practitioner.
   • Link: Ballotpedia
2. End Abortion in the USA
   • Summary: The Moral Outcry is a petition aimed at making abortion illegal in all 50 states in the USA. The petition was instrumental in the reversal of Roe v. Wade and continues to push for comprehensive abortion bans nationwide.
   • Link: The Moral Outcry

These petitions represent the diverse and often conflicting views on abortion laws in the UK, highlighting ongoing debates about gestational limits, sex-selective practices, and the broader legal framework surrounding abortion.

---

Heavenly Father, we humbly beseech You to forgive the countless sins committed by mankind, for we have strayed far from Your commandments and fallen short of Your glory. Grant us Your boundless grace and strength to persevere in Your service, that we may walk in Your ways with steadfast hearts, ever seeking to do Your will. We place our trust in Your infinite mercy and ask for Your compassion and forgiveness…

Miserere nobis

---